7 ms·
Many of the famous Jews are only Jews in the same way that Steve Jobs is Arab. E.g. Dylan, Einstein, Marx.. The point is that there is precedent in letting the
by bjourne 13y ago
Many of the famous Jews are only Jews in the same way that Steve Jobs is Arab. E.g. Dylan, Einstein, Marx.. The point is that there is precedent in letting the minority itself decide which persons are members of it and which are not. We should extend the same courtesy to all minorities.
- msvan 13y agoI'd say the person should decide himself if he is a part of the minority or not. Did Steve Jobs ever identify as Arab American? I've never heard of it.
- bjourne 13y agoReasonable idea, but just as subjective as any other criterion. That's why I wrote that it was a courtesy to let the minority's criterion be the favored one.
- coldtea 13y ago>there is precedent in letting the minority itself decide which persons are members of it and which are not I've never heard of this precedent of seen it in action. We think of Marx or Dylan as jews because we've read their biographical information, not because some jewish minority decided we should do so.