5 ms·
There is not a single mention of open source. The situation is over the decision to choose ODF vs. OOXML. Both seem to have open specifications. ODF - https:/
by gtirloni 13y ago
There is not a single mention of open source.
The situation is over the decision to choose ODF vs. OOXML. Both seem to have open specifications.
ODF - https://www.oasis-open.org/committees/tc_home.php?wg_abbrev=office https://www.oasis-open.org/committees/tc_home.php?wg_abbrev=...
OOXML - http://www.ecma-international.org/publications/standards/Ecma-376.htm http://www.ecma-international.org/publications/standards/Ecm...
- userbinator 13y agoWhat's wrong with HTML+CSS? To be honest I wouldn't choose anything XML based, but ODF looks like the lesser of two evils; the OOXML specification is just monsterous.
- eponeponepon 13y agoI'm not sure what reasons there could be to avoid "anything XML based" yet still favour HTML. Can you explain further, please?
- CodeWithCoffee 13y agoThese standards don't just cover 'word documents', they also cover other Office types for spreadsheets and presentations. HTML+CSS is a terrible idea for a spreadsheet standard.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Argorak 13y agoMediocre page break support, just to start with. (there is some for print media in CSS, but nothing fancy)
- _random_ 13y agoXAML is much better then both.
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoThe actual recommendation is to use the web for communication, with PDF/A as a second choice for read-only printable docs and ODF is then suggested for editable documents.
- bad_user 13y agoThe OOXML specification is dirty, being plagued with compatibility issues with older MS Office versions and full of non-XML streams that are barely specified or things that rely on MS Office in order to be interpreted. As a result, no OOXML document can be opened in non-MS Office software and get the same result. In fact, Word/Excel documents created in the Windows version can barely be opened in MS Office for OS X, because the OS X version is always lagging behind, always lacking features, like macros. I routinely got and still getting Word/Excel documents that I can't view in MS Office on OS X or in LibreOffice in Linux, because users can't help themselves in using totally useless features and also can't be convinced to use more portable formats, because in their worldview, what could be more standard than MS Office? OOXML is Microsoft's response to ODF - they released it because governments started worrying about keeping their data in binary formats. But make no mistake, OOXML is just a farce, meant to sidetrack a real standard from happening.
- VMG 13y agoThis still isn't about Open Source but about legislating file format suppot. > I routinely got and still getting Word/Excel documents that I can't view in MS Office on OS X or in LibreOffice in Linux, because users can't help themselves in using totally useless features and also can't be convinced to use more portable formats, because in their worldview, what could be more standard than MS Office? That's very sad, but where does this end? I don't like PSD files, force Adobe to implement XCF? It sets a bad precedent if government can dictate software features. Edit: I misinterpreted the situation -- the government acting as a customer should be able to set conditions of course
- rg3 13y ago> It sets a bad precedent if government can dictate software features. I don't think there's anything wrong with the government dictating software features for the software they want to use. If anyone doesn't want to implement a specific feature, that's totally fine. But their software won't be eligible for government use and working with official documents. After all, it's public money and documents may better be saved in a good and properly documented format so anybody could, in theory, open them now or in the future.
- aDevilInMe 13y agoThere is an indirect mention of open source. Microsoft argue the act of not paying for a licence will not reap any rewards, in fact it will do just the opposite, as there will be a loss of productivity. "Modern productivity applications are not selected on the basis of the file formats they support, but on the value they provide and the personal productivity they enable. This clearly transcends the cost (or otherwise) of any license. "