3 ms·
> Do I hate Japan for World War II? [...] I said, "No, we're cool with Japan. We've done some good stuff together." And he was like, "Cool." No we are not cool
by rdtsc 13y ago
> Do I hate Japan for World War II? [...] I said, "No, we're cool with Japan. We've done some good stuff together." And he was like, "Cool."
No we are not cool. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731 is not cool, still not cool. I won't repeat the horrific things that happened there, read it for yourself, but no, just saying "we are cool" about it goes a little too far.
> Is Microsoft circa 2014 worse than Google, Apple, or Facebook? We're not nearly as organized as we'd need to be to be as evil as you might think we are.
Microsoft has been, as most people perceive today, de-fanged. It was a scary monopoly, it was pushing crappy APIs, not following standards, perverting them. That legacy crap is still there. It is still maintained. Someone deals with it. So it wasn't just about browser wars. Imagine perhaps Facebook merging with Google so now everything you do online or anywhere on your computer is controlled by one company. That was kind of how Microsoft was viewed.
So, true, there isn't as much reason to hate anymore. But there is a lot of reasons to not forget as well.
What does that mean in practical terms? It means I won't be jumping on or using any Microsoft technologies if I have a choice. F# looks awesome, but nope, I am not touching it. Maybe Visual Studio 2014 is going to be really great, but I won't even try it. If it is tied with .net anything, not touching it.
> Moreover, I think that Microsoft is very aware of perceptions and is actively trying to counter them by actually being open.
Too late. Open source Windows if you want to be open. Open source your browser if you want to be open. Go back and fix your broken APIs and start following standards. Google as much as many don't like it (and I am in that camp too, when it comes to privacy), has to be commended for being open and contributing to Open Source. So use Google as your example in that respect.
- sz4kerto 13y agoGoogle is not open-sourcing software core to their business. None of it. So your request to open-source Windows and pointing to Google as an example to follow is ridiculous at least.
- sounds 13y agoGoogle uses Linux on the bulk of their machines and actively contributes to the Linux kernel.
- sz4kerto 13y agoI said core business. Don't know why is it so difficult to read the whole comment, it wasn't long. If Google wanted to, they could migrate to FreeBSD quite quickly and you would not notice too much. Google's core products are: Plus, Hangouts, Chrome, Search, Docs, Mail, and all these products on Android. They're the same to Google as Windows is to Microsoft. Yes, Android is open source, the rest aren't. And what consumers call Android is not free/libre either. I have no problem with that, and I'm not criticizing Google, just saying, that companies very rarely open source their core business stuff.
- nl 13y agoChromium is open source (and Chrome is just Chromium tied into Google services). Your point is valid though.
- frou_dh 13y agoPresumably those big online services expect to be run on top of Google's backends rather than my garden variety VPS, so what it would mean to package them for open source release isn't clear.
- rdtsc 13y ago> Google is not open-sourcing software core to their business. None of it. So your request to open-source Windows and pointing to Google as an example to follow is ridiculous at least. Android's core is open source. So MS would have no problem releasing their source to Bing ?
- yread 13y ago> Android's core is open source. > So MS would have no problem releasing their source to Bing ? What is the line from Android to Bing? Does google open source google? gmail? Asking for open sourcing WinCE or NT kernel would be a valid point. Both are products that date from ~20 years ago so it's probably not gonna happen. EDIT: also Android is based on Linux code. It would be illegal to distribute it without source
- bad_user 13y agoAndroid is based on the Linux kernel. User-land is not required to be open-source. Dalvik, Android's SDK, all user-land libraries, the whole of open-source Android is not required to be open-source. You may notice that the license is Apache 2.0, a license that's incompatible with GPL v.2 ;-) > What is the line from Android to Bing? Does google open source google? gmail? The line is that Bing is not core to Microsoft, but complementary, so why not open-source the technology behind it? In fact, Bing is even less important for Microsoft, than Android is to Google, because Android for Google is their insurance that they'll stay relevant in this mobiles connected world. Without Android, Google would be at the mercy of the various walled gardens that popped into existence, a trend started by Apple ... quick question, can you set Google as your search provider on Windows Phone? Maybe you can, but I can't do it on my Nokia Lumia. There is no way to make that search button open Google and the option in IExplorer doesn't work. Open-sourcing Bing would be great for everybody, including Microsoft, just like when Yahoo open-sourced Hadoop. Yet, they won't do it - because they are the same bastards, that's why.
- yread 13y ago> The line is that Bing is not core to Microsoft, but complementary, so why not open-source the technology behind it? Fair enough. It is a server software, though. How much server software do companies usually opensource? The point that Android as a whole doesn't have to be open source is true. But how much linux- (or other opensource) based software does MS distribute where it open sources only the needed parts? None, AFAIK. So none of its products are in a similar position. It does distribute sources with plenty of their proprietary software, though. Admittedly, for many it does it only because it has to to stay relevant. People want to fiddle with the sources of their web stack. In short, yes, they are bastards, just as any other for profit company. Oh and for the search you have to jail break WP7, in WP8 it is possible http://www.nokia.com/gb-en/support/faq/?action=singleTopic&topic=FA139224 http://www.nokia.com/gb-en/support/faq/?action=singleTopic&t...
- junto 13y ago> No we are not cool. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731 is not cool, still not cool. I won't repeat the horrific things that happened there, read it for yourself, but no, just saying "we are cool" about it goes a little too far. I think you've missed the point. You can't blame a Japanese child for the sins of his grandfather. The same goes for a German child whose family has a Nazi past or an American whose ancestors slaughtered native American women and children like they were animals.
- rdtsc 13y agoNo I didn't miss it, it was just a bad original point. Microsoft is not a child, it is a little too cute of a metaphor. Microsoft is a bureaucratic organization. Just like Google and also governments. Most important, it is effectively the same entity. Japan is still Japan. US is still US. Google is still Google, and Microsoft still Microsoft.
- gtirloni 13y agoYes, nothing ever changes. What a sad world.
- waps 13y agoIf you lived in Europe you'd see an obvious truth : people are blamed for what their grandparents did, if it's about WWII and nazis. Forget about joining the military, politics, judicial system or police. Well police is a special case. There's a few regions where you won't be able to enter the police if you're not a nazi (despite everything they still exist), but the vast majority the reverse is true. Anything reeking faintly of nazism, like a wrong last name, and you're locked out. It also definitely affects your job prospects in the private sector.
- rdtsc 13y agoYes I am aware of that, I lived in Europe for a long time. The difference, and I pointed out, is between an individual that inherited a last name from another individual (their parent) and a large entity like a company or country. Microsoft is still Microsoft, US is still US. Unless Microsoft was bought or acquired somehow and assimilated, it is still itself. Because mind you, German government is still paying restitution back to its victims. US still prosecutes and kicks out those 90 year old concentration camp guards. My point was that equating Microsoft to a child is a little too much. It was a bad analogy to start with. In summary, I do not support discriminating again children based on their last name. That is not right. But I do support not forgetting what companies and countries did. Especially if they haven't made amends or taken steps to distance themselves and remediate the past wrongs.
- gillianseed 13y agoHe says, 'Microsoft is aware of perceptions' and then they go and join Oracle in their attempt at having API's copyrightable, seriously? Overall I can just ignore Microsoft because they no longer impact me as a developer, but if they and Oracle manage to make API's copyrightable it will have a huge negative effect on software development, in particular interoperability, the fact that they are aiding Oracle in this crap shows me that they are not changing their tune at all.
- dserban 13y ago> "So, true, there isn't as much reason to hate anymore. But there is a lot of reasons to not forget as well." Hate is perhaps a strong word, but I'd say being acutely aware of whom you're dealing with is still in order. Microsoft never ceased to be hostile. I can point to 3 specific things in recent memory to illustrate that: - 2008: Corrupting a standardization process - 2010, ongoing: extracting royalties from people who don't use their technology (Android royalties) - 2012: Throwing a monkey wrench at Linux install fests (by more or less goading laptop manufacturers into this SecureBoot thing). Here's hoping that Nadella is a more level-headed guy than Ballmer was, and this trend stops.