4 ms·
Even if I concede all that, in the meantime, we've had the "Secure boot" fiasco and some other things I don't remember distinctly. I just remember constantly tr
by andrewflnr 13y ago
Even if I concede all that, in the meantime, we've had the "Secure boot" fiasco and some other things I don't remember distinctly. I just remember constantly trying to fight the instinct to hate, to give MS the benefit of the doubt, but I just can't do it.
When discussing past wrongs of an institution, the question to ask is not "how long ago did they do it?" but "has the institution changed since?". In Microsoft's case, the answer seems to me to be "not enough".
- einhverfr 13y agoOne thing I have learned though is that large companies almost never deserve the benefit of the doubt when it comes to their interests or motivations. Is Microsoft any more evil than Google? No, and they are probably less so these days. Google strikes me as more deeply invested in defence informatics and surveillance than Microsoft, for example. But am I going to run out and use Windows Phone because it is the lesser of evils? Definitely not. Lesser of evils unfortunately has proven very successful in American politics. But it has very little place in business.
- bad_user 13y agoWindows Phone cannot be the lesser of evils because it is very restrictive and cannot be forked. Plus Microsoft is making more money with Android through extortion. So no, they have a long way to go before they can earn my trust again.
- jongalloway2 13y agoIn what way has the "secure boot fiasco" actually impacted you? I read a lot about it a few years ago, but in my experience that was nothing but FUD.
- dTal 13y agoGive it time. So far the worst effect has "merely" been to introduce needless hassle and obstacles when installing non-Microsoft operating systems [1]. Microsoft's current hardware certification spec (that manufacturers tend to implement so they can put "Certified for Windows 8" on the box) requires that the user be able to switch off Secure Boot (generally taking the entirety of UEFI with it) as long as they are not on an ARM system. They could change this at any point, and unification of ARM and "PC" is a current trend at Microsoft of which the move to Secure Boot on both platforms is already a part. Forgive me, but I'm not ready to accept Microsoft having me by the balls just because they haven't clenched their fist yet. Secure Boot's purported threat model is a solution looking for a problem ("boot sector viruses" in 2014?). It doesn't really make much sense to make the boot process entirely unmodifiable on the grounds that "malware might modify it". Malware might modify anything else on your system too, and you are pwned either way. So it's probably safe to assume Microsoft had a different motive. I don't think it's wise to think of it as over-and-done-with. [1] http://mjg59.dreamwidth.org/9844.html?thread=328308 http://mjg59.dreamwidth.org/9844.html?thread=328308
- andrewflnr 13y agoIt hasn't, because I haven't yet needed to buy a new computer. But if we can only call out moral wrongs when they personally affect us, we may as well stop calling it morality at all. If you're saying it is, in fact, not prohibitively difficult to securely install an arbitrary operating system, then I would honestly be delighted to see some proof. But all I heard was that the signing keys couldn't be changed, and it was difficult to get things signed so they could be booted, and that's enough to make me angry.