4 ms·
Most boxes like "Open Connect" pay to be colocated and connected that way. Netflix insists on free installation.
by sp332 13y ago
Most boxes like "Open Connect" pay to be colocated and connected that way. Netflix insists on free installation.
- ef4 13y agoNot true. Big CDNs have been cutting deals like this for a long time. It's often in a network owner's financial interest to host a node for free, because it saves them so much upstream bandwidth which they would otherwise pay for.
- bifrost 13y agoMost CDN's pay money for this...
- ef4 13y agoThat's pretty hard to generalize. I worked at the biggest CDN for many years. They definitely get free traffic in many places. They had a whole team who's job was talking to network owners and saying "look, you paid for X terrabytes of traffic to us last month. We can cut that cost by 100 if you let us install servers inside your network that will cache the popular content locally." It all depends on relative size. Bigger networks can demand money from smaller networks and/or CDNs. Networks of comparable size can profitably peer with each other without exchanging cash. Comcast may not do it for free, but the national ISP in a smallish developing country sure might. It's a big dance, and the relationships are constantly changing. Managing it all in software to actually optimize cost and performance is a big part of the secret sauce for a CDN.
- MiguelHudnandez 13y agoYeah, it's a value proposition. The argument ISPs keep using is that Netflix traffic is costing them too much. I don't think Netflix should have to engineer a solution to that problem AND pay the ISP for the privilege of saving them tons of money. If the costs (4U of rack space, networking equipment, and network engineering around privacy/security) are more than the ISP would save, it's an easy decision. Note that in this case, it does not appear to be the use of an appliance. If that were the case I think we'd see the Netflix content coming from a Comcast IP.
- exelius 13y agoNo; no ISP would ever run externally managed equipment inside their network. They would run it in a separate cage with a direct fiber connection to the gateway routers. Rule #1 of network security is that you never run someone else's equipment inside your network; you ALWAYS make them go through a gateway. Also it's largely semantics where a device like OpenConnect is hosted. Netflix could host it at a datacenter across town with a direct fiber interconnect to the ISP and it would be effectively the same thing. This is how all the big CDNs do it; that way they host equipment once and connect to multiple local ISPs.
- philp 13y ago> No; no ISP would ever run externally managed equipment inside their network. You haven't been paying attention to that Edward Snowden fella, have you?
- waps 13y agoJust stating the obvious here, but "Rule #1" obviously doesn't apply to service provider networks, who are specifically built so other people's equipment can be connected on almost every point. Customers on the access layer. Datacenters, colocation and these sorts of boxes on the distribution layer, and peers on the "gateway"/peering layers. The second paragraph is wrong too, there are much closer relationships possible. They're much deeper than that today, and I would expect in the future to see CDNs much deeper in provider networks.
- dsl 13y ago> This is how all the big CDNs do it You have no idea how big CDNs do it. I've personally installed CDN gear into ISP racks. Sometimes you get an uplink into a router, other times you sit on a switch with other gear. That "direct fiber interconnect" is called private peering and mostly used to fill cache boxes on the providers network.
- exelius 13y agoLarge ISPs sure as hell don't do this (maybe they used to; but not in the last 3 years). They have dedicated cages in their datacenters for external gear that sit at the edge of their network. Regardless, the word on the Netflix-Comcast situation is that Netflix is indeed hosting the hardware at 3rd party datacenters with a dedicated connection to Comcast. Whether you call it an interconnect or private peering is just semantics; it's a pretty common practice in the industry and technologically, it's no different than having a 10gig fiber link within a datacenter.