2 ms·
"My point is that its silly to hold the UDHR as some evidence of social consensus given how many on this board alone would disagree with many of its provisions,
by dllthomas 13y ago
"My point is that its silly to hold the UDHR as some evidence of social consensus given how many on this board alone would disagree with many of its provisions, especially libertarians."
Right, my intend had been to grant that (at least for this thread).
"Ultimately, a right is more than an aspiration. Its a social norm so established that other people will defend it on your behalf. At the global scale, pretty much the only thing that meets that standard is the right of groups of people not to be exterminated by genocide. That's the only thing that will get the international community to take up arms."
It strikes me that there is a tremendous gulf between use of "human rights" in the sense of prosecuting people for violations or using force to prevent them, where we need broad agreement to exist and want it made explicit; and use of "human rights" in the sense of "I believe these are things all humans are entitled to", which one would like to see elevated to the former level but might not be there yet. When we're talking about what our government's behavior should be the latter is relevant, as abiding by norms strengthens them.
- rayiner 13y agoNorms that aren't enforceable aren't "rights" they are aspirations or opinions. The UDHR has lots of aspirations, stating that people should be provided the basic necessities of life, but without real buy-in, those are just someone's opinions. Moreover, talking about "rights" which are mere aspirations makes the argument of "we shouldn't do X because it violates peoples' rights" utterly impotent. "We shouldn't spy on other people because I believe that people are entitled to privacy." Okay, and your beliefs are special because? If you can't cite some concrete basis, either in law or broad and deep social consensus, you're just expressing your opinion, but trying to make it seem more authoritative than an opinion.
- dllthomas 13y agoI think you're overlooking some pretty self-evident truths, here.