2 ms·
That's not a ridiculous framework, but I think your application of it is misguided. Unless you think that there exist agents with those moral capabilities that
by dllthomas 13y ago
That's not a ridiculous framework, but I think your application of it is misguided. Unless you think that there exist agents with those moral capabilities that we're overlooking, or countries made up entirely (or even primarily) of those lacking those capabilities then "human rights" is a correct label, to a pretty good approximation for our discussion here and others are going to better understand what you mean if you use the term.
- logfromblammo 13y agoIt isn't really a matter of who we may be overlooking. Though in that case, any species that passes the mirror test deserves additional scrutiny for its members to determine if they are or are not people. True AI does not yet exist, but it will, and once it does, we might want to have something better than Asimov's Laws in place. We might create new biological species. There is also the indeterminate probability of encountering personhood-compatible aliens. The important thing about the structure is that humans are not automatically considered people with rights. The defining characteristic is the moral capability. If you cannot or will not support the common-law structure, it will not support you in return. That creates a significant burden on the civilization for identifying its predators and parasites, and deciding what to do with them, but we do this all the time anyway, in the form of criminal investigations and jury trials. But in order to keep everything from collapsing on itself in the current system, you really do have to assume that all humans are people with rights until they have proven otherwise beyond all doubt, because even if they are not upholding the fabric of civilization today, they could start tomorrow. Species groups like great apes, pachyderms, corvids, and cetaceans show potential, but so long as you have to keep the crows off your crops with force rather than a politely-worded notice, they won't have any standing to complain when they get shot. The primary case for a framework not specific to humans is AI, but I wouldn't rule out the possibility of an extraordinary mutant bonobo or business school graduate somehow qualifying as a person.
- dllthomas 13y agoSure. But then it remains the case that "human rights" is a good approximation, and I think we're not yet near enough the point that it ceases to be that consciousness raising is more important than effective communication - so I'd encourage you to at least accept (and possibly use) the term, except where explicitly marked as an aside.