6 ms·
Honestly, I think what kills it is that it's not an Algol-descended language [1]. If Erlang was written with an Algol-esque syntax it would have taken off years
by jerf 13y ago
Honestly, I think what kills it is that it's not an Algol-descended language [1]. If Erlang was written with an Algol-esque syntax it would have taken off years ago. But instead it has this weird syntax, which it then doesn't really do that much with. What do I mean by that? Haskell has a radically different syntax, but it does things with that syntax and its pervasive currying to enable a powerful succinctness that one can not imagine being translated back into the Algol-esque framework. Lisp does things with its bizarre syntax, making it obvious how to write correct macros and being homoiconic, which translates poorly back into Algol-esque infix languages. It's almost inconceivable that one could translate a concatenative program back into Algol-esque syntax [2]. But Erlang really doesn't do anything that couldn't be in Algol-esque syntax. (Near existance proof: Go. Yes, there are significant differences, but the two are inter-transliterable to a much greater degree than any pairing of any of the previous sets of language families.)
If it had an Algol syntax, and performed the SSA transform behind the scene, it would probably be very, very big now.
Bear in mind as I say this that I'm not necessarily advocating for those changes. For instance, this would require some tweaks to the semantics of pattern matching, too, which aren't necessarily for the better... in the abstract. However, they probably would be for the better in terms of usage.
I'm pretty sure Go is going to eat Erlang. Erlang programmers will 100% absolutely correctly complain that OTP can't be translated without loss into Go, and almost nobody will care. Again, I'm not necessarily advocating for this, because the Erlang advocates will be right, you just can't quite get it fully expressed in Go and that saddens me, it's just what's going to happen, I think.
In fact I'm doing it myself; the Erlang core of my system is getting pulled out and replaced by Go for a variety of reasons, and one is despite the fact my team is fairly adventurous over all, we're still better off finding people to work on Go than Erlang. (In the next couple of months I hope to release my first release of "reign", "Rewrite Erlang In Go Nicely", which brings some of the Erlang stuff into Go for the purpose of porting existing programs. I've been pulled into other fire fighting so I'm not on it this second, but I'll be getting back to it soon. That implements Erlang-like mailboxes and network clustering, and I've got a supervisor tree implementation on deck for Github too. Subscribe to https://github.com/thejerf https://github.com/thejerf to see when those come out in the next couple of months.)
By the way, Erlang advocates, bear in mind that trying to argue me out of this position is a waste of time. I've been programming in Erlang for 7 years now. I get the syntax just fine, even if I still don't like it. The problem is that you have to argue the greater programming community out of this position, and I don't think you have, and I really doubt you can. For better or worse, being non-Algol seems to put a hard limit on your general-purpose programming acceptance. (In my opinion, that is for the worse, but here we are. Again, please don't mistake this opinion as celebration of any of these facts. My opinion is that Erlang deserves better. My belief is that it won't get it.)
[1]: That's pretty much every modern mainstream language today: C(/++/#), Java, Python, Javascript, etc. Not all those languages come from the same semantic heritage (scripting vs. conventional OO manifest types being one big example), but they come from the same syntactic heritage. Contrast with the ML family, the Lisp family, the Prolog family (which is pretty much just Erlang now), and the Forth family for different syntactic heritages.
[2]: http://evincarofautumn.blogspot.com.es/2012/02/why-concatenative-programming-matters.html http://evincarofautumn.blogspot.com.es/2012/02/why-concatena...
- Nogwater 13y agoNot knowing enough about Erlang/OTP or Go: Would it be possible for more of OTP to be replicated in a Go 2.0? What's missing? What would it take? What can never be replicated?
- seiji 13y agoErlang is like Lisp in that once you build a language up to a level of "reliable disturbed system language," you've basically re-implemented Erlang.
- limmeau 13y agoIs "disturbed system" intentional? Nice term for a bunch of processes which are expected to die occasionally.
- jerf 13y agoYou can recover a substantial portion, but there's a few things you can't quite get back. Since Go is a mutable-state language, and also a shared-state language (isolation is by convention, not by language design), you have to live with the consequences of that. In my supervisor tree implementation, the restart of a monitored goroutine is just to fire off a new goroutine on the exact same object again; if you still have bad state lying around and immediately crash again, well, too bad, the supervisor can't do anything about that. (Except not thrash the processor with endless restarts.) In contrast, when an Erlang supervisor restarts a process, it is guaranteed to be a fresh process with no shared state from the one that just crashed. It's much more likely to not immediately crash. (I fiddled with having the user specify a closure that is supposed to "create" a new object for the restart, but then simplified that away when I realized that the closure itself could well have mutable state too. Better just to stick with the simpler interface and document the consequences of failing to clean out state at the beginning of your monitored code. On the plus side, so far the interface for the supervised-things is "Serve()" and "Stop()", and nothing else; hard to argue with that level of simplicity!) You also won't ever be able to recover live code restarts; you can try to transfer all state to a new process, including file handles, but that's a lot of implementation work. (I'm stuck right now on the fact that my connections are encrypted, and the encryption code won't let me even get to the state, let alone transfer and reconstitute it somewhere else. Someone's got some code for moving file handles around on GitHub but I can't seem to Google it up.) Most people already live in a world where live restarts are difficult or impossible, though, so they won't miss that. Getting a REPL into a live Go server is impossible, at least with Go itself, and will also probably never be as clean as Erlang. (Go "2.0" could fix that with an official Go interpreter, which is the missing bit. I can handle the sockets, I can bind readline and give you a nicer REPL, but interpreting Go is a challenge. Progress is being made, I believe as part of the new compiler implementation, but I'm not sure anyone has this as an explicit goal.) Again, most people live in a world where they already don't have a REPL into their running code, and therefore won't miss this. There's also some more subtle semantic differences, but I'm saving that for a blog post. (It gets long, especially if I first have to explain Erlang, which is what the blog post does.)