3 ms·
> Is it really an "overreach" if the NSA can acquire the mobile phone records of Yemen "indiscriminately Yes. You can not commit act of violence indiscriminate
by belorn 13y ago
> Is it really an "overreach" if the NSA can acquire the mobile phone records of Yemen "indiscriminately
Yes. You can not commit act of violence indiscriminately just-in-case.
The US army could place a bomb under every house in Yemen, just in case that they would need to bomb it later. Would that be an overreach? If they don't activate them, how can it be harmful?
- rayiner 13y agoDealing with the necessities of the real world means drawing lines, and just because it may be ridiculous to draw the line in one place does not mean that the whole exercise is ridiculous. At the opposite extreme: even if a terrorist is heading at you with an AK-47, you shouldn't "commit an act of violence" because what if he chances his mind and decides not to shoot you?
- belorn 13y agoThat is comparing indiscriminately violence to self defense against a specific identified person. The lines are not that silly. Yes, you can defend yourself against someone pointing a gun at you. No, you can not use a nuke, or release biological weapons that kill indiscriminately everyone in the whole nation. Reactions should be appropriate to the threat, and indiscriminately violence is rarely if ever appropriate.
- rayiner 13y agoWhere is anyone releasing a nuke or a biological weapon indiscriminately at people?
- bediger4000 13y agoIt's a "reductio ad absurdum" argument. You know, test for the extreme values that can be passed into a function to see if that function can handle them. If it can handle the extremes, and a few other values correctly it probably handles everything correctly.
- res0nat0r 13y agoWhere in the world did we start talking about bombing in the comment above? He is talking about passive communications collection.
- belorn 13y agoPassive communications collection is extremely dangerous. If data get leaked, people are going to die left and right. If the data is somehow incorrect or corrupted, innocent people will die. Surveillance is violence. It is that simple.
- jamesgeck0 13y agoFirst you mention ways in which surveillance could result in violence, then you equate violence and surveillance. Doesn't your own argument indicate that they are separate concepts? It doesn't seem simple at all.
- belorn 13y agoThat is a very semantic way to look at it. If a bomb explode, people die. Thus I (incorrectly?) equate violence and bombs even if they are technically two separated concepts. Any weapon, be that information or bombs or what have you can technically be disconnected with the violence they create, but its a very dishonest thing to say when the army uses it in a war zone.
- happyscrappy 13y agoYou didn't equate bombs with violence, if you had you would have a chance of winning your argument. You equated intel to violence. Edit: Just to be clear so you can't try to weasel out of what you said, troops need to be fed so food is violence. Is that clear to you?
- belorn 13y agoIm commenting to "win an argument". If you want to believe that information that direct drones where to send missiles are equal harmless to food, then have a nice day.