18 ms·
I am not sure this is actually a true statement about libertarians, rather than a standard polemic. Libertarians often come to that belief by being skeptical ab
by jerf 13y ago
I am not sure this is actually a true statement about libertarians, rather than a standard polemic. Libertarians often come to that belief by being skeptical about any concentration of power... it just so happens that the US Federal government is today the biggest concentration of power, so you hear about that one the most. Thanks to crony capitalism, the line between "government" and "big business" can be a hard one to find. The general solution proposed by the supposedly-non-naive non-libertarians is to... give the government more power. Why it is supposedly so obvious that this is the correct solution to the problem of that we can openly mock anyone who disagrees is, frankly, unclear to me; the evidence that more government power has decreased large corporation's power anytime in the recent past seems pretty lacking, if you ask me. It seems to have just made the purchasing of favors that much easier.
- jbooth 13y agoSo, just to bring the abstracts down to earth for a bit here, you're defending things like the Citizen's United decision here? Let's get rid of the laws against outright bribery of congressmen while we're at it. That's just giving the government more power, with more laws, right?
- zanny 13y agoTrying to make illegal the paying off of politicians only skates the root problem that you have a society where enough wealth is concentrated to enable the buying of legislation from supposedly democratically elected representatives. Even if you managed it, you still have an absurd over concentration of power and wealth you aren't doing anything about, that just continues to corrupt at all levels of society.
- jerf 13y agoIf the purpose of your message is to convince me to stop being libertarian, trying to explain how I'm actually in favor of bigger, more powerful government as your last paragraph does is a very ineffective way to do it. I'm in favor of breaking down big power structures, where ever they are. As for the liberal's bete noir the CU decision, I'm pretty ambivalent. It would be far better to break up the big power pool the Federal government represents and thereby make capturing it less useful, then to try to make one big pool of power then insist that people try not to acquire it. The whole thing is the wrong question.
- jbooth 13y agoI'm explaining that calling out "a law against bribing the government" as "more government power to oppress the private sector!" illuminates the silliness of putting everything on a single axis. I'm not trying to convince you to "stop being libertarian", I'm trying to convince you to stop being anything-ian. Get in the gray zone, man. It's where actual understanding or admitting that you don't understand happens. Libertarians these days remind me of nothing so much as college marxists. It's all about theory and ideology, nothing about the real world.
- gopher1 13y agoYou're falling into the trap. It's not a question of more or less government. Just like it's not a question of socialism vs capitalism. We know that some problems are best solved when society pools its resources, and other problems are best solved by market forces. For those problems where pooling society's resources is the way to go (healthcare), it's a question of what are the "regulations"? Are they effective at preventing corruption? Or, are they built in order to facilitate corruption? The devil is always in the details, and that's what matters, not whether there's more or less regulation. Take healthcare for example, if we went single-payer, that's a government solution, but it also requires far fewer regulations than the current system. There are systems that can be put in place that are simple and effective at serving the general public. The reason they don't get put in place is because big business has captured the legislators. Is this the fault of government, or is this the fault of big business? I think we need to fight to put in place those simple, effective systems and not eschew all government. People's memories are short, but we've seen what happens when the government is small or non-existent.
- jerf 13y ago"It's not a question of more or less government." To be honest, that's usually my line. However I find the balance right now is so grossly in favor of the government being given all the power (to the point that on the so-called "libertarian haven" of HN, libertarians are routinely openly mocked for their beliefs, almost uniquely amongst the political orientations here) that it is not an unreasonable approximation to speak of the government just having power stripped from it. That takes some structure to pull off (many of which were actually written into our government, and defanged in various ways over time), and that's why I'm a libertarian and not an anarchist, but there's no contradiction, precisely because liberatarianism isn't anarchism. As with the other message, if the point is to convince me that I shouldn't be a libertarian, one should probably avoid arguing against anarchism instead. In the meantime, I can't help but notice the frequency of the basic argument 1. Sometimes governments need power. 2. So, yeah, they need this power too. Just that. Bare, plain, and simple. Also I love "The government invented the Internet, so, yeah, they need to spend trillions of dollars on everything."