3 ms·
The Senate isn't supposed to be democratic, that is what the House is for.
by protomyth 13y ago
The Senate isn't supposed to be democratic, that is what the House is for.
- dllthomas 13y agoThat's the way the system was designed, yes, and I'm not failing to understand that. That doesn't change the fact that it is undemocratic, and if democracy is something we value then it's a legitimate consideration. More is not always better, but at extremes it's a concern. I'm not saying we should turn the Senate into a purely democratic body. I'm saying that when we consider how we draw our state lines "how democratic it makes the Senate" is one relevant factor. As I said, it is also unreasonable.
- protomyth 13y ago"if democracy is something we value then it's a legitimate consideration" I don't think we've ever valued democracy for its own sake. The founders were much more focused on the States and checks and balances. Democracy had to fit into that framework. [Edit] the proper rights of a British subject became the proper rights of an American citizen and should affect the House directly.
- dllthomas 13y ago"The founders were much more focused on the States and checks and balances." First, quite obviously, the borders of California were no part of that deliberation. Second, the focuses of the founders don't have to be our own. They had legitimate concerns, of which we should also not lose sight, but that doesn't mean democracy is an illegitimate concern.
- protomyth 13y agoI think we ought to go back to listening to the concerns on the proper balance between the people, states, and federal government. We have done a poor job of it in the 1900's and 2000's.
- dllthomas 13y agoI've no objection to having that discussion, but it's pretty well orthogonal to "should we split CA?"