4 ms·

Have any of those libraries been audited so far? Seems like a necessary step for widespread js crypto.

by benzim 13y ago

rarrrrrr 13y ago
SJCL had substantial peer review during its development, but I'm not aware of a public 3rd party audit from a security firm. Oh yeah, and before people with torches show up, let me clarify that is a Javascript based crypto product but not browser and website based crypto. The deployment target is situations where the code delivery problem is solved: HTML5 mobile apps (including phonegap / cordova), desktop apps with things like AppJS, browser extensions, etc. It's a high level secure-by-default framework for building collaborative realtime and storage applications. Javascript is a natural language for this, because the framework provides storage through an object database, and that approach is natural an convenient in Javascript. We're spending the time and money to make a secure framework now so we don't have to spend quite as much time in reinvention and security review for each new crypto application we build.
- tptacek 13y ago
  SJCL has been audited. You should ping me via email if you're serious about arranging for OSS crypto to get reviewed, not because I want to sell you audit services, but because someone already beat you to the punch in a big way, and you should talk to them. :)
  - deezthugs 13y ago
    Will do! Thanks! Is there a public report available? How long ago was this?
    - tptacek 13y ago
      There's no public report available.
- sasas 13y ago
  So to be clear - we are not implying that these routines should be used in the browser right? http://www.matasano.com/articles/javascript-cryptography/ http://www.matasano.com/articles/javascript-cryptography/
deezthugs 13y ago
Not that we can find evidence of. SJCL is written by some of the best security people around. I have confidence in it - running in a "safe" runtime like a cordova app or extension. This is a library used by so many - it makes sense to try to crowd-fund an ongoing set of audits.

Have any of those libraries been audited so far? Seems like a necessary step for widespread js crypto.

by benzim 13y ago

Have any of those libraries been audited so far? Seems like a necessary step for widespread js crypto.

SJCL had substantial peer review during its development, but I'm not aware of a public 3rd party audit from a security firm. Oh yeah, and before people with torches show up, let me clarify that is a Javascript based crypto product but not browser and website based crypto. The deployment target is situations where the code delivery problem is solved: HTML5 mobile apps (including phonegap / cordova), desktop apps with things like AppJS, browser extensions, etc. It's a high level secure-by-default framework for building collaborative realtime and storage applications. Javascript is a natural language for this, because the framework provides storage through an object database, and that approach is natural an convenient in Javascript. We're spending the time and money to make a secure framework now so we don't have to spend quite as much time in reinvention and security review for each new crypto application we build.

tptacek 13y ago
SJCL has been audited. You should ping me via email if you're serious about arranging for OSS crypto to get reviewed, not because I want to sell you audit services, but because someone already beat you to the punch in a big way, and you should talk to them. :)
- deezthugs 13y ago
  Will do! Thanks! Is there a public report available? How long ago was this?
  - tptacek 13y ago
    There's no public report available.
sasas 13y ago
So to be clear - we are not implying that these routines should be used in the browser right? http://www.matasano.com/articles/javascript-cryptography/ http://www.matasano.com/articles/javascript-cryptography/

deezthugs 13y ago

Not that we can find evidence of. SJCL is written by some of the best security people around. I have confidence in it - running in a "safe" runtime like a cordova app or extension. This is a library used by so many - it makes sense to try to crowd-fund an ongoing set of audits.