4 ms·
Tear apart my consulting page
Marketing sucks. It's ambiguous, it lags, its results are questionable, it suffers from too much bullshit, and it's full of quasi-professionals.
I created a single-page site[0] to promote my consulting biz, and tried to cut through all the nonsense. But I want you to rip it apart so I can improve it.
[0] http://www.gkogan.co
What's your first impression? Would you recommend me to a friend? Does it wreak of BS? Is the value proposition clear, or confusing? What questions come to mind? Let me know!
- codezero 13y agoLooks good to me. The only thing I'd add or change is probably not even huge, but rather than testimonials some concrete and brief case studies with the kinds of numbers that your work affected would be more compelling.
- gk1 13y agoThat's a good suggestion. Going straight to the to-do list.
- raquo 13y agoLooks good in general, here are some potential improvements: * You can safely drop "I'm a conversion optimization consultant." The sentence that follows is more powerful and easier to understand. * "How I can help." – titles should not end in periods. This one as well as "Happy clients." can optionally end with a colon. There are a couple places in the text where punctuation is also incorrect, you should re-check it against English rules. * "Conversion Optimization" should be to the left of "Funnel Tracking & Analysis" because it's simpler, IMHO. * The bullets under "Funnel Tracking & Analysis" don't really say much about how it brings money, just what it is. * On Chrome in OS X with standard settings, "Funnel Tracking & Analysis" is split into two lines. Layout looks a bit broken because of that. * "How can I help?" assumes that the client knows the answer to that question. Don't intimidate them, either drop or rephrase this. * Why no email? You can add it using javascript, and the vast majority of spam bots won't see it (google how to do that properly).
- gk1 13y agoAwesome, thank you for taking the time to write that, Nikita! All things going on to-do list. About the "Funnel Tracking & Analysis" title... I'd love to simplify that to just "Funnel Analysis." Would that lose too much meaning?
- raquo 13y agoYou welcome! I think "Funnel Analysis" is better. Tracking is kinda implied in the whole conversion / funnel optimization thing, and presumably the value is in analysis & optimization, not tracking per se, so that's what should be in the title.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoFewer fields in the contact form - I mean why have a textbox? I am contacting you about conversion optimisation surely? Just grab my email or even better have a mailto: so I can say hi remove full stops from h2 add full stops to li (personal annoyances) What if my startup has no funnel? What if I have no traffic to optimise? these seem lie bigger issues for l
- gk1 13y agoThank you, Paul! The headline fullstops are really catching a lot of flak. ;) They're gone now. > What if my startup has no funnel? Do you mean if the conversion process does not have a funnel, or if they're just not tracking it yet? > What if I have no traffic to optimise? Good question. As I see it, going from 0 traffic to 1,000 is a whole different beast than going from 1,000 to 10,000. The former often requires not just optimization but marketing from the ground up, branding, product development, and so on... All of which can easily turn into a full-time job for one or more people.
- rufusjones 13y agoMy first impression was {CRINGE}, to be blunt. You seem talented-- and you asked people to tear you apart-- so let's see if you mean it. Let me give you about $1,000 in free work. 1. The first thing you need to understand is what you're up against. No one has ever explained the obstacles a consulting company is up against better than the first 52 words in McGraw-Hill's "Man in the chair" ad. This 1958 ad has repeatedly won in "Best business ad ever" votes. It's here: http://bit.ly/165CAuy http://bit.ly/165CAuy Print that out and put it where you can see it. 2. I had to break out the machete to cut through the jargon. Other than "Bottom line: You'll get more customers and lower your cost per acquisition." this takes work to read. The man in the chair won't read it. Make it simpler. You're assuming customers know what a funnel is? On what basis? 3. I can't click on anything relating to and see who you are? An "About" Page (or section would be nice, but I need a LinkedIn page at minimum. 4. Same goes for the two people giving you references. I want to click on the photos and go to the LinkedIn pages so I can see who they are. And I absolutely have to be able to view the but the company website-- not just to see if THEY'RE any good, but to see if YOU are. Your work is there, right? I can see it and be overwhelmed by the quality of your work, can't I? 5. You put the link to your Twitter page and blog (where prospects can read your insights for free) at the BOTTOM of the page? Seriously? 6. I hate Flash, but even Jakob Nielsen has colors other than black and white. A logo would be nice, too. 7. I don't need to have your address and cell number, but can I know what country you're in? A state and city would be even better. 8. People argue about this, but since I have 11 of my 12 points from this, I'll say it: If I don't have any idea of how much you cost, I'll probably pass. You don't have to put a rate sheet on the page, but it would be nice to know if you charge $5, $50, 5500, $5,000 or $50,000, so I don't waste both of our times.
- gk1 13y agoAmazing. This is why I asked to be torn up! Thanks for doing that -- lots of useful points there. Most of those are quick fixes (adding rates, adding location, etc), but obviously I have some work to do on the language (your #2). I'm trying to balance between being specific about what I do and writing in very simple language. I'll keep looking for that golden middle ground.
- 13y ago
- ohsnap 13y agoI am reading this from the perspective of an early stage startup: Biggest need for a start up is (typically) proving their business model and understanding how far it can go in terms of market size. Speak to that directly. Explain how you can much more quickly validate or invalidate their current approach. Am not so interested in optimization than having someone that understands my business and can push us to get the right message to the right customer. You recommendation from Steve expresses that well, I'd suggest to emphasize that more in your copy.
- gk1 13y agoThanks for that! I wonder whether start-ups in your position are more hesitant to pay for consulting, since they're still (relatively) new. Would you hire a consultant at the stage you're in to help you validate/invalidate your approach? Not trying to pitch you, just want to get your point of view.
- ohsnap 13y agoSure, startups will pay for consulting. Most valuable thing at a startup is time. If you can convince a company that you can validate their current approach faster than they can by themselves it's a great value proposition.
- chatmasta 13y ago> Marketing sucks. So why are you going into the business of it?
- gk1 13y agoI meant that the process of marketing usually sucks. I want to make it easier for people, and that's why I'm offering marketing consulting.