4 ms·
Its an interesting theory. And frankly I hope the Supreme Court comes down solidly in Aereo's favor. The theory goes I can put an antenna on my roof and watch T
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
Its an interesting theory. And frankly I hope the Supreme Court comes down solidly in Aereo's favor. The theory goes I can put an antenna on my roof and watch TV in the living room, I can put an antenna on top of an apartment building and watch TV down on a lower floor which doesn't have line of sight visibility. If I were rich I could put an antenna on a nearby mountaintop, run a line (with signal boosters and conditioners) all the way to my apartment in the city and watch that. So I should be able to do all of that but using the network cable between me and my antenna as the coax.
And that runs up against some of the fairly ridiculous rules that content providers have been throwing up for years to extract money out of consumers.
So far the courts have been somewhat irrational on the topic but as technical sophistication increases I keep hoping this house of cards will either collappse or be burned to the ground.
- mjn 13y agoMy guess is that the Supreme Court will be skeptical, because it looks too much like an attempt to get around streaming rules with a sham antenna that exists solely to get around streaming rules. I'm not that confident in that prediction, but I would be more surprised if they win than the reverse. Another company that could in theory do something like that is Netflix. Currently they have streaming rights to a certain set of films, but they can rent you physical DVDs of a larger set of films. Could they eliminate that gap by setting up a "remote DVD viewing experience" service for the remainder? For the films where they have the streaming rights, they stream directly. For the films where they don't, they simply robo-insert the DVD into a player, hit play, and stream the output to you... which amounts to streaming video of the film, just with some robotic shuffling of DVDs to give it legal cover. My guess is this wouldn't fly either, but it's hard to say for sure.
- NolF 13y agoThere was a company that did remote DVD streaming, exactly in the fashion and with the intent you describe. They lost on court [1] with a $1.8m payout. [1] http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2011/10/streaming-movie-service-zediva-pays-hollywood-1-8m-shuts-down/ http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2011/10/streaming-movie-ser...
- mjn 13y agoInteresting, I forgot about them. It looks like that case was never really resolved legally, though. They lost one injunction in a District Court, and then shut down, so the underlying issues weren't fully litigated (and not considered by higher courts).
- nknighthb 13y agoNo, they settled out-of-court and shut down after a preliminary injunction by a district court that effectively bankrupted them. There's no precedent there, and no hint of what the result of an appeal would have been.
- eli 13y agothere was an mp3 company in the 90s that did the same thing, but I doubt the RIAA actually was able to get a precedent.
- anigbrowl 13y agoAnd that runs up against some of the fairly ridiculous rules that content providers have been throwing up for years to extract money out of consumers. Broadcast spectrum ain't free. If you're paying hundreds of thousands of dollars in FCC license fees, and millions on mandatory local production (eg news operations) and network content licensing costs, you might look askance at it too. I really think the whole individual aerial thing with Aereo is bullshit.
- kyllo 13y agoOf course it isn't free, but that's why there are ads on it.
- chrisBob 13y agoRight. And the whole point is that the ads are targeted at a local audience.
- kgermino 13y agoOk, and... Does a viewer suddenly become "not local" if the signal gets to their house through the internet instead of an antenna? The studios aren't concerned that someone will switch from an antenna to Aeveo, they're worried that someone will switch from cable to Aeveo. Even broadcast channels have been getting into the re-transmission fee game and they don't want to give it up. Frankly, I'm not worried that their business model is being disrupted. The other issue is that ratings aren't well tracked for streams. This is more a problem that Nielson or someone similar needs to correct but it is a problem. And unless/until Aeveo viewers are counted in the ratings the broadcasters get no benefit from their existence.
- danielhughes 13y agoThe local targeting of ads is actually a minor point. Six minutes per hour of the ads you see are local ads, twelve minutes are national ads sold by the parent network. Also, Aero shows you the local affiliate stream so you're still seeing the local ads. At its core this case is about content rights.
- rayiner 13y agoTechnical sophistication has nothing to do with this. Aereo's technology isn't complicated, or innovative, in a way courts have trouble understanding. It's a fairly low-tech workaround for rules that draw an otherwise easy to understand line between over the air broadcasts and streaming. The argument Aereo is making isn't a technical one, it's a nitpicky lawyer-ly loophole-y one. It's clearly a streaming service, but because there's a physical antenna involved, it shouldn't be subject to the same rules as other streaming services?
- ChuckMcM 13y agoRay its more sophistication with the meaning of the technology as it applies to the law versus the law itself. The Google v Oracle trial gave us some good examples of what 'understanding' looks like in the judiciary, specifically in understanding that you have to use the same name for a Java method if you want to be "compatible" (widely protected as fair use) even though the words/characters are identical which looks like written text.