4 ms·
how are you going to create a generative process that seriously engages how and where the biases emerge? E. T. Jaynes would have said that you do this using yo
by pdonis 13y ago
how are you going to create a generative process that seriously engages how and where the biases emerge?
E. T. Jaynes would have said that you do this using your knowledge of the physics of coins and coin flipping. One of the examples he uses in his book Probability Theory: The Logic of Science is a robotic coin-flipper that can control the process so as to always make the coin land on the same side, i.e., the "bias" is in the flipping process, not in the coin itself. If you don't know anything about the flipping process or the relevant physics, then you have no way of constructing any hypotheses about what sort of generative process might be involved.
It is far easier to just say "empirically, biases seem to be distributed like so."
This corresponds to the case where you don't know anything about the underlying physics; in Bayesian terms, you are assuming a maximum entropy prior with a constraint--the constraint being the distribution observed in the flips so far. But if you do know something about the underlying physics--for example, if you know the coin is being flipped by a robotic flipper with such-and-such design--you might be able to come up with a much better prior using that knowledge. I'm not sure whether that sort of thing is included in the frequentist's concept of a "generative model".