3 ms·
"First, a failure to communicate doesn't have to mean that either of us is dumb. It just happens sometimes." Agreed. I'd meant my other comment to better indi
by dllthomas 13y ago
"First, a failure to communicate doesn't have to mean that either of us is dumb. It just happens sometimes."
Agreed. I'd meant my other comment to better indicate that those were potentially transient attributes. Also, smart people are perfectly capable of lacking understanding about something in particular.
"Second, the thought that you might be trolling has crossed my mind as well, so it now seems unlikely that either of us are."
That doesn't really follow, but okay.
"Third, there really isn't any need to repeatedly resort to insults. I have no idea what you do for a living but I wouldn't be so ready to dismiss you as incompetent as you seem to be with others."
I apologize where I was overly rude or confrontational.
"Security by obscurity is generally used [...]. I hope I've done a better job of explaining the statements I made, I can see how they may have been overly vague, but I was focusing on your claim that the SSID broadcasts aren't a valid example of security through obscurity."
It still seems to me that you're more or less using it to mean "weak security", as opposed to a principle which can be used to guide what to fix. It's quite possible that the meaning has weakened/broadened since I first learned about it (plausibly here[1], though I feel like it was earlier), but if so I think that's unfortunate - I think the tie to Kerckhoffs' Principle is important.
">Seriously, where do you work anyway?
This is extremely unnecessary and unproductive."
You brought your profession into the argument. I'm not sure it's extremely unnecessary to establish it, or for the argument to reflect on your profession. Neither am I entirely sure that it was actually appropriate, though.
[1]: https://www.schneier.com/crypto-gram-0205.html#1 https://www.schneier.com/crypto-gram-0205.html#1