3 ms·
The protocol component in BTC to firm confirm a trade is not at this time entirely amenable to buying and selling one million times per second or whatever. May
by VLM 13y ago
The protocol component in BTC to firm confirm a trade is not at this time entirely amenable to buying and selling one million times per second or whatever. Maybe one transaction per minute?
Also there's no arbitrage opportunity where buying nine shares of a NYSE stock at 2.01 and one share at 2.00 means the "real" price is 2.009 but the NYSE stubbornly won't trade in fractional pennies (made up example numbers). The BTC transaction would just be one simple 2.009 transaction not some foolishness involving ten thousand trades or whatever.
You could have a BTC derivative market with somebody acting as the market maker just like NYSE, although thats kinda at cross purposes to the whole idea of a distributed currency.
There is no market maker so picking winners or losers by deciding who gets to front run vs who doesn't, is also kind of meaningless.
Or the TLDR short version is no it isn't gonna happen due to some inherent design issues.
There are some interesting issues. There's no particular technological reason GOOG couldn't say F the stock exchanges and issue a derived cryptocurrency and let people arbitrage between their new stock equivalent and the rest of the world. Well, there are a couple legal and accounting issues, but like I wrote, no technical issue.
Would not be totally surprised to see a BTC-like infrastructure replace existing monolithic market maker trading structures. Probably the same crooks owning the whole works, I'm talking about it as a deployed technology not a social phenomena or whatever. Much as running TCP/IP in 2014 doesn't mean anymore that you're part of DARPA.
- maxerickson 13y agoMtGox is essentially doing what you are talking about, allowing people to trade bitcoin derivitives (that they supposedly back 1:1 with real bitcoins). Trades on MtGox don't hit the blockchain.
- VLM 13y agoYes, exactly, and as I wrote "although thats kinda at cross purposes to the whole idea of a distributed currency." A great plan if you want to buy coins for $632.58 and end up getting $260 for them because of a centralized system failure in an inherently decentralized protocol. There's an old saying about idiots, idiot proofing, and long term trends in idiot breeding under idiot proofing environmental conditions. So invent a decentralized massively redundant system, someone WILL find a way to centralize it, and SPOF it, yet still blame the designer when it blows up. Like a law of human psychological nature.
- caseydurfee 13y agoWhy don't we just call Mt.Gox what it is, a bucket shop?