5 ms·
IT consultant paid £2,000 a day to cover civil servant's job
- nmc 13y agoIt's funny how brobdingnagian salaries have to get for people to feel shocked. Would it be OK for only £1,000 a day? £200 a day? Seriously, where is the limit?
- infosecbuzz 13y agoWho knows? But It´s easy to see how so much money is wasted...
- negamax 13y agoAccording to the article, the recruitment was from the private sector and pays the market rate. If this was nepotism, then I would had agreed with the waste argument. But just because someone is being paid 10x the majority, doesn't make the decision to recruit them wrong.
- infosecbuzz 13y agoIt doesn´t make the decision wrong. It´s a supply and demand game isn´t it? It´s hard not to second guess in this matter, but you have to presume that the cost to replace them is much greater.
- marvin 13y agoIt's easy to get up in arms about consultants being paid a high rate. But who really knows how much time and money was wasted among the 50,000 staff that was laid off? This is a very difficult question to answer, since "performance" can't be measured accurately.
- rmcastil 13y agoExactly. A consultant's job is to deliver results from day one. If not, they're quickly out the door. The same can't be said for staff because they are considered an investment by their employer and therefore kept around much longer despite how much the drop off in "performance" may be compared to a consultant.
- Daviey 13y agoFor the top rack, which is this... short term contract, I am not outraged. Should I be?
- Nursie 13y agoExcept the article says it's not really short term and she's overseeing several long term projects. The public sector in the UK is notorious for keeping these 'temporary' people in place at great cost to the taxpayer.
- Daviey 13y agoThe article precisely says that "It is understood that Ferguson is on a short-term contract".. And the fact that she has prior top-end contracts with RM and TfL proves that she will not be there forever. It's too easy to assume situations like this are 'at cost' to the taxpayer, it's probable that it is a net saving to the taxpayer.
- Nursie 13y agoIt's very unlikely this is a net saving to anyone, Capita are involved.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- swombat 13y agoThis article is highly misleading. Shoddy reporting from the Guardian there. She's not on a £2k/day salary, that's just the rate paid to Capita, a consulting company. For a senior person (e.g. partner-level), £2k is actually on the cheap end. I went for £400/day 10 years ago as a Junior Software Engineer fresh out of uni, and by the time I left my day rate was about £1k/day. (My rate was from Accenture - somewhat more high profile than Capita, but shows that £2k/day of chargeout rate is not so extraordinary). In case this was not obvious, neither myself not Ms Ferguson take home anything close to the day rate - back when I was being sold at £400/day my own salary was a whopping £22k p.a.
- keithpeter 13y agoIt does mention that the £2k is the charge paid by MoD further down the page, although I admit it could be clearer. Good luck with the messaging on this one when the wider press get hold of it.
- joosters 13y agoBut the point of the article is that the MOD is trying to cut costs. The takehome wage of Ms Ferguson is irrelevant, she is still costing the MOD £2k/day. IMO there is a reasonable story here: is the ministry really saving much money by laying off staff and then, as a result, being forced to bring in contractors at much higher costs?
- theknown99 13y agoThe Guardian has an agenda, and they routinely misinterpret things to sell news. They're the "daily mail" of the left. Happily, judging by their circulation figures, they won't be around too much longer.
- eterm 13y agoThe Guardian is funded by a trust. It is losing money but the circulation figures mean little: Print is dead.
- jkahn 13y agoLooks like a perfectly fair consulting rate for someone with the skill to be CIO of a large organization.
- DanielBMarkham 13y agoDo we really have to re-explain the difference between short-term costs of things like rentals and long-term costs of things like employees? This lady is a rental. You need a rental to give you breathing room to find an employee. Very sorry, but there's nothing much to see here. This is just attention-seeking.
- obayesshelton 13y agoI have worked for various different companies where they pay developers up to 3 times less than contractor developers and in some cases I have seen companies have more contractors to developers for long periods of time. I understand contractors are useful but they are not worth 3 times more.
- stevebrowne 13y agoremember a number of things (in UK at least): Employee hidden costs: Employers NI, PAYE, car allowance, holiday pay, sick pay, maternity pay, paternity pay, training, pension, healthcare Contractors have to pay all of that from their turnover - along with professional indemnity insurance, public liability insurance, accountancy fees etc. And note I said turnover. There seems to be this misconception that all contractor payments go straight into the contractor's pockets. They don't, they are business receipts that go into a company. That company then pays the contractor. What contractors do get is the ability to shift things around as they see fit. Employees are stuck with whatever structure of payments to make up "the package" is decided by the higher ups.
- dkrich 13y agoSo what's more expensive, hiring an expert at $4k/day who by herself in one month can accomplish what an entire team of complacent government employees probably can't in three years or keeping around a staff of employees who for the most part probably are grossly under-qualified to perform this kind of work? This article reeks of a lazy financial assessment of this investment (ie, person A is really expensive in dollar terms so we should be appalled that the government laid off person B who was paid 1/100 of this sum).
- rainmaking 13y agoIt sounds like for the 2000 quid a day she's building systems that will replace the jobs of thousands of civil servants. If this is true then the real outrage here is that it's a pretty good investment.