5 ms·
NZ court rules Megaupload warrant legal, dealing blow to Dotcom
- DerpDerpDerp 13y ago> However, the appeals court upheld an earlier ruling that prosecutors had not been authorized to send clones of seized electronic evidence to the United States. > A New Zealand government enquiry in 2012 found the nation's secretive spy agency acted unlawfully by giving information on Dotcom to U.S. authorities before the 2012 raid. Does anyone know if anybody actually got in trouble for this?
- rainmaking 13y agoTime to retaliate by taking Libertarian activism up a notch. Here's an example how: Stores in a Berlin tourist neighborhood began opening on Sunday all at once. The council let them because it would be too embarrassing to fine them all. They found a niche where the law says government has power, but Realpolitik says it does not. I swear I'm going to find as many of those as I can in my everyday life, and I will use them. Who's with me?????
- polymatter 13y agoTaking on the local council over stupid historical-accident religon-based laws that actively damage a major local industry during difficult economic times is one thing. Taking on your national government, and directly challenging the authority and interests of the US at the same time, is quite another. I'm not trying to be defeatist, but you'd need massive civil disobedience Ukraine-style before NZ decides to soften its stance on "piracy" (or more properly, copyright infringement).
- rainmaking 13y agoI believe your assessment is correct. Massive civil disobedience is to the local council as hitting a home run on national television is to batting practice.
- icu 13y agoI think the problem in NZ (like most of the western world) is that individualism has overtaken collectivism and the climate for collective social revolution isn't present anymore. People may stick it to the Man in a personal way, but not collectively. Your example of the businesses banding together isn't quite a Libertarian example, more like a Capitalist response of maximizing profits in the face of constraining government regulation. If life was harsh, or the political institutions totalitarian or corrupt, then collective social revolution would eventually appear. New Zealand is so far away from that type of environment that I doubt it will ever see the type of Libertarian activism that would be required to make lasting social change. 1. Lifestyles in NZ are good, and it really is quite a lot more egalitarian than the USA or UK. New Zealand ranks 11th in the world for Quality of Life Index. 2. Political institutions are not totalitarian or corrupt. New Zealand ranks the lowest in the world for corruption (equal to Denmark) in the Corruption Perceptions Index [http://cpi.transparency.org/cpi2013/results/ http://cpi.transparency.org/cpi2013/results/].
- rainmaking 13y agoThis is not about revolution. That would not be prudent; the inevitable destabilization frightens people into agreeing to more centralization of power. This is about widespread ignoring of government, which is then forced to agree to save face.
- yeukhon 13y agoI used to use megaupload when I was much younger. It was fast, reliable and easy to use, compared to other ones (4shared, RapidShare for example). MU had probably the best bandwidth for upload and download. As I got older, I can afford something. I went ahead and got a Netflix account to celebrate my first internship (yeah, literally, I thought that was the best way to celebrate...). But a lot of great movies are missing from Netflix and I didn't feel like renting one from Amazon Videos or Youtube store. $3.99, $5.99? Meh. Only a few times because I was desperate to see watch them. From time to time, I was hoping MU was still alive. I would find a link easily. Putlocker took the lead after MU went down. That's probably the most popular domain to view illegal contents. I prefer to have high-quality video. As I grow older, I am side with the music and film industry. I want to pay. I still go to theater for awesome films. I don't know if people have studied how bundle HBO, movie on demand into cable TV ever helped subscribers to reduce the incentive to download illegal contents. My guess is some good percentage of individuals probably feel less motivated to get illegal contents if they could just find them from their on-demand channel. I know making a film or making a music album is a big investment. But ultimately, owning a DVD is going to sound old and useless in a decade. Everyone wants instant play, or digital copy on their device. I am glad the music industry is becoming more open to streaming service (thanks to iPod and iTunes - though Apple wasn't really the first one to do that, but Apple pushed it). I can listen to free legal, high quality music on Spotify, 8track, soundcloud, pandora. I am just waiting for the film and tv industry to become more open :) I really hope that one day, I can turn on my computer, and select a movie I want to see and I get to see it. Last, I still like going to movie theater. I don't mind if new movies won't be available right away on Netflix until the new movies are away from theater.
- junto 13y agoI'd love to have been a fly on the wall when the US government started calling the NZ government and making promises (and threats) to make sure this happened. It would be naive to think otherwise. The USG is amazingly patient. Kimble has been on their radar for a long time. Now they really want him, and I would be very very surprised if they don't get him eventually. Somehow I really think he has a small chance to stick it to the man, so I kind want to root for him, even though he's more than likely a tool.
- ChuckFrank 13y agoActually, Kim Dotcom is not a tool. He's very well spoken, intelligent and surprisingly compelling individual. Here's the Campbell Live interview - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMcvYhQwAC8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMcvYhQwAC8
- icu 13y agoGood link, thanks.
- brazzy 13y agoHe's a crook who'll do and say just about anything for his personal enrichment and self-aggrandization.
- junto 13y agoCorrection: > He's very well spoken, intelligent and surprisingly compelling individual _fraudster_. Mega wasn't exactly the first time he's been in trouble [1]. The MCI / AT&T calling card fraud was a lot of money. The Letsbuyit.com fraud wasn't small fry. He's a fraudster through and through. The only difference between his actions with Megaupload and the previous frauds was that this time he was defrauding media companies and not the man on the street. The man on the street was on his side, mainly because he was enabling them to get free content. The English Wikipedia page also misses out on another rather nasty part of his history, namely [2][3]: > And he copied all data he found, and brought the captures to Germany’s most hated intellectual property lawyer, Günter Freiherr von Gravenreuth. Who sued the hackers on behalf of the copyright owners and allegedly paid Schmitz per bust. So yeah, he's a tool. He fucked over his fellow crackers for money. On a side note (just in case you falsely think I'm some kind of RIAA / MPAA lover), I also think that the same media companies that are screwing over their customers using copyright law are also a bunch of fraudsters, but sadly they are doing that screwing within a legal framework that they have lobbied congress to impose. More fool congress and more fool the voter who voted for those jokers. - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Dotcom#Criminal_investigations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Dotcom#Criminal_investigati... - http://eclamus.wordpress.com/2012/01/26/megaupload/ http://eclamus.wordpress.com/2012/01/26/megaupload/ - http://cd.textfiles.com/thegreatunsorted/texts/bbs_legal_info/busts.txt http://cd.textfiles.com/thegreatunsorted/texts/bbs_legal_inf...
- icu 13y agoThere are a lot of political things going on in the background with this case. 1. New Zealand (NZ) desperately wants closer economic ties to the US but is constrained by public sentiment Because New Zealand is primarily a low value added commodity export based economy the NZ Government and NZ businesses highly covet lower trade barriers. However NZ's anti-nuke stance and lack of military spend means that NZ will never get free trade agreement. Therefore anything else the NZ Government can do to appease US counterparts wins NZ small favors. This is why NZ is very much in bed with US spooks and basically has a US intelligence facility in Waihopai. I firmly believe that this was a primary reason for the NZ Government's willingness to let their US Government counterparts to run the operation on Kim Dotcom. 2. NZ has been trying to woo the US film and TV industry The NZ Government has been doing its best to entice the US film and TV industry even before the success of The Lord of the Rings (circa 1995 with Hercules: The Legendary Journeys). I'm of the opinion that the heavy handed nature of the raid on Kim Dotcom was to send a message the NZ Government takes the rights of film and TV studios seriously. That said, I think the NZ Government didn't properly gauge how far public opinion would swing against them for being so heavy handed against Kim Dotcom. Kiwis love an underdog and when the local TV media showed video footage of the raid on Kim Dotcom complete with helicopters and SUVs it certainly looked like an absurd Hollywood action movie. Also the use of the Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB) to spy on Kim Dotcom unnerved many Kiwi's sense of privacy. After this recent ruling I'm not sure how this whole saga will play out. I imagine that with with his personal freedom at stake, Kim Dotcom will keep pressing his case through to the Supreme Court of New Zealand.
- omh 13y agoHowever NZ's anti-nuke stance and lack of military spend means that NZ will never get free trade agreement Is this an official policy? Why is nuclear such a big deal, and how does the military factor in? Is it just that those are the major things the US would like to sell to NZ?
- xlevus 13y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Zealand%27s_nuclear-free_zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Zealand%27s_nuclear-free_z... Yep, it's the law. Much to the chagrin of the US. Their Military has no Nuclear weapons, and the population is pretty strongly opposed to anything nuclear, instead favouring 'green' technology. I'd go as far to say, as it's now so entrenched in NZ's identity, if any government that tried to repeal it, it would be an act of political suicide.
- tjaerv 13y agoA government court ruled in favor of the government? You don't say?
- meepmorp 13y agoI see a lot of folks suggesting that the ruling is somehow evidence of intergovernmental pressure or elsewise improper. Is that just based on how you'd like the case to have turned out, or is there some greater level of familiarity with the laws and jurisprudence of NZ than I'd have expected at HN? Is it possible that the warrant was ok and that the initial ruling was in error? At any rate, according to the article there seems to be another court which can hear an appeal, so it may not be entirely decided yet.