3 ms·
IMHO, one huge thing they got wrong with Windows 8 Metro/"Modern UI" on non-touch computers was to repurpose the right mouse button in a completely unexpected w
by pavlov 13y ago
IMHO, one huge thing they got wrong with Windows 8 Metro/"Modern UI" on non-touch computers was to repurpose the right mouse button in a completely unexpected way.
On a Windows 8 tablet, you swipe up from the bottom of the screen to open the "control bar" of a Metro application (I don't know what is the official name of that UI element). This is crucial to know because the bar is hidden by default, yet it contains fundamental actions like deleting a message in Mail or navigating to a URL in Internet Explorer.
When using a mouse instead, you're supposed to right-click to bring up the "control bar". This is completely non-discoverable and also goes against every established UI convention: for the past 20+ years, the right button has been used for context menus, but suddenly in Metro it brings up a hidden application-global menu instead.
Windows 8.1 tried to fix this by adding a button in the corner that brings up the bar, so at least you can find it by clicking around. But that's still not good enough. The bar makes sense on a tablet where screen real estate is limited and the swipe feels very natural, but on a desktop it's just a bad toolbar implementation that adds extra mouse navigation to simple tasks because people never figure out the right-click shortcut.