5 ms·
(Another professional cartoonist here.) I strongly disagree with the suggestion of starting with cartoons first. Start with real anatomy first. Books that sho
by gk1 13y ago
(Another professional cartoonist here.)
I strongly disagree with the suggestion of starting with cartoons first. Start with real anatomy first.
Books that show step-by-step guides to drawing a comic character are only good for one thing: Learning how to draw that comic character, in that position, in that style, in that medium. I hate them. One may look at these books and think that's how all cartoonists (or other artists) learned to draw, and they'd be wrong.
To be a good cartoonist, in my view, you need a foundational understanding, not just technique (which is what these books teach, in a very limited way). Once you understand anatomy, how bodies move, forms, perspective, composition, visual weight, ... Then turning your ideas into a cartoon (or any other form) becomes simply a matter of technique. (And even at that point, learning techniques from step-by-step instruction books is a lousy method.)
- bitexploder 13y agoFor someone who just wants to doodle and play around, while still learning the fundamentals, what resources would you recommend?
- gk1 13y agoI received a formal art education, so my answer may be very biased, but I'd recommend starting with a fundamental drawing class. If you're in NY or SF, there's no shortage of them. If you're anywhere else, you may be able to find one at a library, college, school, or artist organization. But keep on doodling! Even mindless doodling improves your skills.
- jes5199 13y agoI had the weird experience that fundamentals classes seemed to assume that I had much, much more experience than I actually had as a beginner. Is there some distinction between different "fundamentals" classes that people should be looking for?
- gk1 13y agoNot that I'm aware of. I've seen classes labeled as "Fundamentals 1," "Fundamentals 2," etc. I guess just like any other class or course, a lot depends on the instructor. Don't let a bad experience keep you from looking for other courses, just inquire in advance what the course will be covering.
- reeses 13y agoArtists love creating other artists. We all mostly remember the hundreds of a-ha moments that changed our view of the world again. It's sad how eager most of us are to share the knowledge. :) Depending on where you are, you may do well to find a tiny studio with good reviews on yelp or, if you're near a school, look for tutors. In the mean time, definitely keep doodling but occasionally try to doodle something you can see. Then laugh at it and shade a sphere or a cone. :) This is one area where everyone has potential. You just need to develop it with some basic tools, most of which involve ways of seeing.
- themodelplumber 13y agoFirst, watch this webinar or get Mike's book. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oJ7WHuvdsjI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oJ7WHuvdsjI It's a powerful combination of principles and elements of design that should leave you feeling ready to head off in more specific directions.
- avtar 13y agoCheck out the second and third lists here http://ctrlpaint.com/library/ http://ctrlpaint.com/library/ I really enjoy watching videos on these two YouTube channels https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5dyu9y0EV0cSvGtbBtHw_w?feature=g-high https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5dyu9y0EV0cSvGtbBtHw_w?fea... https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrJhSmz4zo9t-Z2GdHECW7A?feature=g-high https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrJhSmz4zo9t-Z2GdHECW7A?fea... Scott Robertson recently released this awesome book https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pNkG5HN4bgY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pNkG5HN4bgY
- vijayr 13y agoI found this video (long) very interesting and useful http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=up3Z7LU2pV8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=up3Z7LU2pV8 Also, check out all videos and books by Bruce Blitz For example - http://www.amazon.com/dp/0762402490/ http://www.amazon.com/dp/0762402490/ Watch his videos on youtube first, to get an idea of his teaching style Disclaimer: I'm not an artist, just someone who has interest in this topic.
- frooxie 13y agoAs a professional illustrator, I disagree with you. Have you read the Preston Blair books? They start with general lessons on how to think about and construct any shape in 3d, and I haven't seen a book with better examples of using lines of action (if you know of any, then please tell me). I think it's a good idea for people to learn to construct simple 3d shapes before they tackle the complexities of human anatomy; it creates a framework for thinking about the drawing. I'd agree that there are better ways to learn drawing than from books, but still, a good book is much better than nothing.
- gk1 13y ago> I think it's a good idea for people to learn to construct simple 3d shapes before they tackle the complexities of human anatomy; it creates a framework for thinking about the drawing. Yep, I absolutely agree. That's what I meant by saying that a foundational understanding is needed first. I've seen parts of the book but have not read the entire thing. If he does have chapters on these foundational elements, then that's good and it's probably a better book than many others.
- frooxie 13y agoIt's not a perfect book, but there's definitely much more to it than just "Follow these three steps to draw exactly this cartoon animal in this exact pose". The very first exercise is to take an actual egg, draw construction lines and a face on it, and then to study it and draw it from every angle.
- egypturnash 13y agoI'm recommending not just the Preston Blair book (which is a classic in the field), but a specific series of exercises by master animator John K that use it for visual reference. These lessons are aimed at getting someone up and running with a solid knowledge of constructing a figure in three dimensions as quickly as possible. You can quite easily stack anatomy on top of this foundation and draw in more complicated styles than "1940s cartoon character"; it's useful to learn construction with those kinds of characters because they're basically little but their construction. I do not by any means discount the value of anatomy lessons and text, life drawing, sitting out in public doing quick observational sketches, frame-by-frame analysis of video, going to the zoo to draw, or any of the other myriad activities that make up part of a serious art education. I did that, and so did everyone else I knew during my time in animation, no matter how stylized most of their final work was. But I think these lessons are a great hand up over the huge gap between "I can copy what I see onto paper OK" and "I can draw any damn thing I please in any pose I like, with no reference beyond a few design drawings". (tangential edit: I'm surprised to find another cartoonist here on HN and curious to see your work, but your website doesn't mention that at all, and Google turns up nothing. Any links? My website[1] is full of my stuff.) [1]:http://egypt.urnash.com http://egypt.urnash.com
- chipsy 13y agoAs an amateur doodler, I agree. I've done the "work through books of anatomy" thing, but at the end of it I still had deformed figures which mixed detailed, textbook-correct anatomy with gross problems in proportioning and alignment - e.g. my upper torso would look okay by itself, but it would float a bit disconnected from the hips as soon as I tried to assume a more difficult pose. I had to use references for all poses to avoid this broken look. My breakthroughs in representation were in large part based on following cartooning material. After that I was able to develop specific construction techniques using primitive shapes in new ways(different shape configurations, mixtures of 2D and 3D conception, inversions that make one shape the framework of another, etc.) that gave the resulting figures a more balanced, focused look. Since then my style has developed primarily around cartooning since it lets me play so fluidly with ideas.
- gk1 13y ago
- tripzilch 13y agoomg I got that book when I was a kid! :D my dad got it for me and my brother (all three love drawing and cartoons). Reading the description and comments ITT, I was a bit confused and kept thinking, "but I had this other book, and it was mainly about cartooning, not anatomy, and it explained things really well". Then someone here mentioned "lines of action" and I thought "wait a minute ..", clicked the link and it was that book :) :) Well, I am glad that I had the opportunity to learn from such a classic when I was young. I have to agree, a lot of the ideas, techniques and really fundamentals stuck with me and shaped my cartooning style over the years. See, anatomy is IMO not the end-all of cartooning. When I hear the word, I think about super realistic sketches of human figures where you can see all the muscles, figuring out how the clothes would wrap and fold around the body, etc. This is important if you want to draw the Silver Surfer or US super hero style comics, but that's never really been my thing. The importance of "anatomy" in cartooning, for me, is limited to the way human body parts are connected to eachother, how they can move w/respect to eachother, and their relative sizes. As opposed to the almost biological/physiological detail I have in mind when I hear "anatomy" with respect to illustrations ... For instance, and this is something that is treated in the Preston Blair book very well, which for me immediately sprang to mind as an example why "anatomy" really is not the end-all of cartooning: facial expressions. Facial expressions in cartoons are nothing like how a human face actually moves. They are caricatured far beyond physical possibility (but not "beyond recognition", as I shall explain). They are NOT based on careful observation of what a human face actually looks like when it experiences a particular emotion. Look at a real crying face, a real hysterical-laughter face, that's not how cartoon characters emote at all[0]. And you can't learn how to do cartoon-emotions by studying actual human faces. Instead, they are based on the biological concept of the "supernormal stimulus"[1]. These don't exist in real life (except where someone else has already drawn/modelled them, advertisements are a good source). You have to figure them out by experimentation, not observation, because you can't know which attributes can be exaggerated for the psychological/biological supernormal stimulus effect (which can be weird and unexpected). Instead, you just draw hundreds or thousands of quick-sketch cartoon faces, with the eyes and the mouth and the ears and whatnot, just-so, randomly trying out weird configurations, anything, and figure out how it affects the perceived mood/emotion of these faces. Or body language. The other option is to copy and try out styles or ideas you like, or happen to notice (same as when learning typography, you start getting an eye for it). Or perhaps like Robert Crumb, do supernormal stimuli by just drawing whatever's your fetish. The Preston Blair book only half-covers this, btw (if I remember correctly, it's been 10-15 years or so...), they talk about baby and toddler like configurations of the face and body proportions. Maybe also the sexual "Jessica Rabbit" type of supernormal stimuli, I forget. These are powerful, but not the only ones that exist. In particular for facial expressions, like chords and scales in music, some very powerful and useful tricks are very weird and unorthodox (or maybe I've just not figured out the reason behind the quirky sequency that is the minor Blues scale, which works so well no matter what you play with it). Either way, my point is these exaggerations are not based on real-life observable phenomena, but on how the human psychology reacts to superstimuli (which you need to create before you can observe the reaction--which, fortunately, is quite easy to do). Also the lines of action. are these based on anatomy? The Preston Blair book has that beautiful example of an animated character throwing a baseball, frame by frame[2]. That's not at all how a human moves IRL :) It is, however, an exaggeration/caricature of what our brains expect of rubbery bouncy physics. You can't observe that in real-life, because it never really happens like that. Another example is the famous Pixar desk-lamp animation. It's not even got anatomy. But it moves according to some weird exaggerated physics model, and it has emotions, what, how? Because it plays to our minds, not real-life. Another note, I'm not a native English speaker, I must have had only a very basic understanding of English when I was 11 or 12. Still, the Preston-Blair book was quite easy to follow, because most of it was explained as illustrations. Just a hint, if any non-English HNer is considering a present for their kids (they have to love drawing first, though) :) There is one "step by step" part of that book which I didn't really like very much, and felt to me (then) it was imposing a certain style too much. This is the bit where it explains how to build a character made from spheres/ellipsoids and cylinders. I never liked first sketching shapes that you were going to draw over and erase later on anyhow. But then, this is probably exactly a type of technique that you'd learn if you'd start with anatomy as well :) I probably learned from that as well, but at the time it felt a bit restricting. [0] which is brilliantly subverted by Ren & Stimpy, with their hyper realistic cut-scenes and close-ups, going one step beyond the fictional cartoon world into the surreal, for dramatic emphasis. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superstimulus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superstimulus [2] thanks to the Internet, you can click and view the cartoon here: http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3vhl1_mgm-batty-baseball-1944_shortfilms http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3vhl1_mgm-batty-baseball-1... the jokes are corny, the cartoon-animation is beautiful. take note how almost none of it is realistic.