3 ms·
Europe, China, and whoever else who would like to one-up Silicon Valley needs to analyze SV's success and weaknesses from first principles. I stress: And Weakne
by stcredzero 13y ago
Europe, China, and whoever else who would like to one-up Silicon Valley needs to analyze SV's success and weaknesses from first principles. I stress: And Weaknesses!
If you don't take this two-sided approach to re-creating Silicon Valley's success, then you run the risk of blindly imitating the wrong things. Also, if you want to not only match but surpass SV, you need to be mindful of such weaknesses.
I have to admit that my sample size is too small to be scientific, but I am starting to suspect that SV startups actually have a rationality problem. Startup founders often have blind faith in aphorisms that have been adopted by the startup community and make decisions on the basis of these "old sayings" and programmer-lore biases while ignoring quantitative reasoning. I recently had an exchange like so:
"We need X so we can scale." (X doesn't run stably and they want me to fix it, but this will be very expensive. Y runs stably, but they don't like it.)
"What does scaling mean quantitatively for your business? Have you worked out those numbers and cranked that through Little's Law and figured out how much it will cost you to support n users?"
"No, we haven't done that yet, but we know we need X because Y would take too much RAM." (But when pressed, they can't quantify what "too much RAM" means with respect to business models.)
Well, I did the numbers myself, and it turns out that Y would just add about 40% to their equipment cost and get them up and running quickly while they're waiting for X to be fixed.
What shocks me even more: None of their investors or advisors had even asked them the question!
- johnjay 13y agoToo many times a manager will try to tell a developer/sys-admin how to do its job based on looking at the problem from a very simplistic view. Don't know the specifics of X and Y but most often than not you should defer to the developer's judgement. Unfortunately many developers are not very good at defending their position and will usually give in to the one that can push their view point harder. Hope that was not the case here.
- mark_l_watson 13y agoGood points. I think the number one Silicon Valley weakness is very high cost of living. I worked in Mountain View last fall and was shocked at the cost of living. I would guess that living costs in my town in Arizona is about 40% of the cost of living in SV. At work, I heard horror stories from co-workers about very long commute times - no way to live.
- nunb 13y agoOther than cost of housing are there very big differences with Sedona in say, grocery or {furnishings, restaurants, car, gas} prices?
- mark_l_watson 13y agoIt is amazing how much less expensive it is in the mountains of Central Arizona: real estate prices are probably 50% less expensive, food perhaps 20%, gas is usually about $0.40 cheaper per gallon, movies less expensive. Also, my wife and I entertain ourselves hiking, kayaking, and hanging out with friends. In Silicon Valley, getting together with people seemed to involve going out to expensive restaurants. That said, we had a lot of fun in Silicon Valley - a really nice experience.
- samstokes 13y agoI'm sure you're already aware of the irony inherent in claiming SV startups make decisions based on "old sayings" and "lore", then justifying that with a single anonymised anecdote :)
- stcredzero 13y agojustifying that with a single anonymised anecdote :) Hey, you pay me enough to do a formal study, I'll do a formal study. In the meantime, that's just one in a number of incidents involving supposed young prodigies in a certain startup incubator with a huge reputation. Which is precisely why I wrote: "I have to admit that my sample size is too small to be scientific," However, it's highly disturbing that I find multiples of these sorts of things in such a highly reputed group -- without even trying. In any case, there is no excuse for someone making a quantifiable declaration about a piece of technology, without even going so far as quantifying by doing a back of the envelope calculation. Those sorts of shenanigans are supposed to be part of the brokenness of BigCo and the PHB. http://zedshaw.com/essays/control_and_responsibility.html http://zedshaw.com/essays/control_and_responsibility.html At least there, internal politics, and salesperson manipulations are the reason. In a startup, there are no such excuses.