3 ms·
The how to make an IC question is a good example of group-think on SO. The question was general and very wide open, but everyone jumped on "how to discourage s
by VLM 13y ago
The how to make an IC question is a good example of group-think on SO. The question was general and very wide open, but everyone jumped on "how to discourage someone from making a modern processor fab plant in their basement" bandwagon. Or not answering the question in a tangent, or going all snarky. The best 5 minute answer to the actual question is probably just to look it up in wikipedia as at
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_circuit#Manufacturing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_circuit#Manufacturin...
The commentary about fab at home was not very interesting, either. The true answer is its very much like making a rocket engine, high performance, cheap, and safe all at the same time requires a nation-state, 2 outta 3 is going to take some engineering skill, only 1 achieved is actually pretty easy at home for an experimenter. Ditto the fab. Twenty people repeating that you're not going to make a ARM proc anytime soon is not terribly insightful, but mentioning the work of the "instruments of amplification" guys and insinuating that once you obtain double digit betas, the logical next step of on die bias networks for a simple class A amp or perhaps a RTL (R, not DTL or TTL) inverter...
SO is notoriously good at groupthink. Sometimes what you need is groupthink, so thats OK. Sometimes not.
- pjc50 13y agoNote: that question has been edited considerably from how it was originally posted, and some of the author's original comments below deleted, in which the questioner was determined to do it at home. EE.SO is very negative about "bad" questions, partly because it's small and can be run for the convenience of the dozen or so people who answer half the questions. I don't entirely approve but I see their point.