7 ms·
Switzerland's Answer to Silicon Valley
- DrJokepu 13y agoBrought to you by the same country whose people have chosen last week to limit the right of free movement of European citizens. This is not a good time to start a technology business in Switzerland.
- patrickaljord 13y agoIt is still a million times easier to establish a business and get residency in Switzerland than in the US for Europeans. So by that standard, it would be an even worse time to start a technology business in the US. And the limits that were voted last week are minimal and temporary.
- DrJokepu 13y agoIn the United States, businesses have access to a workforce market of 340 million people educated to a high standard. In the European Union, businesses have access to a similar workforce of over 507 million people. Without access to the EU workforce, Swiss businesses have access to a workforce market of 8 million people.
- _delirium 13y agoThe overall technical/scientific ecosystem of Switzerland also looks like it will be at least somewhat damaged by this closure. US startups often start off as university spinoffs from NSF or DARPA-funded research (Sun Microsystems, Google, etc.), or as partnerships between universities and industry (a number of machine-learning/data-mining startups fit that category). The same is often true in Europe, just replace NSF/DARPA with the EU research framework (keeps changing names, but essentially the same). It gives large grants to multi-national consortia of universities and companies. Switzerland was part of the 2007-2013 "FP7" program, but they're being suspended from the 2014-2020 "Horizon 2020" program, at least for now. Existing funded projects will be allowed to complete (funding is usually for 3 years), but Swiss institutions and companies won't be allowed to be part of 2014 applications. That's causing a bit of turmoil around here (not Switzerland) right now because people had planned to submit proposals with Swiss partners who are suddenly ineligible. It's possible Switzerland will cover some of the damage by pulling the money they would've contributed towards the EU research framework, and using it to increase domestic research funding instead. Will have to wait and see how that goes.
- chli 13y agoToo bad EU is playing that card since it's obviously a lose/lose situation. "Switzerland's contribution to the total budget of Horizon 2020 of about EUR 81.6 billion sums up to around CHF 4.4 billion, over a seven-year period. The corresponding budget appropriation was approved by the Federal Assembly on 10 September 2013." http://www.sbfi.admin.ch/themen/01370/01683/index.html?lang=en http://www.sbfi.admin.ch/themen/01370/01683/index.html?lang=...
- chli 13y agoExcept businesses still have access to EU / US workforce.
- DrJokepu 13y agoOnly via a tedious visa sponsorship process. Thanks, but no thanks.
- parennoob 13y agoSilicon Valley is not much better -- it chooses to keep immigrant engineers from specific countries employed at the same job for 10-15 years at an almost fixed wage by utilizing the broken immigration policies of the US, which have country-specific quotas. The only reason most of these people (myself included) don't speak out is that they have been schooled to be grateful for the fact that they have a job in a "developed" country. ["If you don't like it, just leave!"] Which is, admittedly, our situation -- so we STFU. It feels like one of those dreams when you want to open your mouth and scream...but no sound comes out. I'd rather work in Switzerland any day, even with their proposed system (which is supposed to come into play after 3 years, and has quotas).
- antr 13y ago> The Arc Knows No Borders says the Swiss bank of Switzerland, the country that has closed its boarders. Last week's immigration referendum has certainly closed any hopes of Switzerland benefiting from a diversified, thriving tech industry. Europeans will go to London, Berlin, Paris, Madrid, Amsterdam, etc before going to Switzerland.
- ithkuil 13y agoDid it close the borders even for highly qualified workers "invited" by the companies? If no, is this so different than the U.S.?
- antr 13y agoThey are implementing quotas. No different to the US. Hence, "Switzerland's answer" is status quo.
- ThePhysicist 13y agoNo, the Swiss referendum that was carried out last week (and which the commenter refers to) was about stopping a treaty on "free movement of persons" which Switzerland was about to sign with the European Union. Such a treaty would have effectively allowed citizens of the EU to live and work in Switzerland without having to obtain a visa or residence permit first (it would not have allow them to profit from social security or other benefits, though). Since the referendum was accepted (though with a really thin majority of 50.3 %) it will force Switzerland to renegotiate the treaty with the EU, which in fact already suspended further negotiations with Switzerland by itself. Immigration of qualified workers will still be possible and encouraged by Switzerland, though. I think the main motivation behind the referendum was the fear of "Überfremdung" (foreign infiltration), which is probably not entirely irrational with currently 25 % of people living in Switzerland being of foreign origin. So I think one should not overreact here.
- chli 13y agoWe've had the "free movement of persons" with the EU for over ten years now in Switzerland ! [1] And yes social security and other social insurances are also valid for EU people working in Switzerland.[2] [1] https://www.bfm.admin.ch/content/bfm/en/home/themen/fza_schweiz-eu-efta.html https://www.bfm.admin.ch/content/bfm/en/home/themen/fza_schw... [2] http://www.bsv.admin.ch/soziale_sicherheit/index.html?lang=en http://www.bsv.admin.ch/soziale_sicherheit/index.html?lang=e...
- gavanwoolery 13y agoA lot of hate for Switzerland, but honestly I don't blame the Swiss from wanting to keep the rest of Europe out (so to speak). I think Switzerland has the sanest government in the world, and the balanced budget to prove it.
- collyw 13y agoThey get a lot of their money from hiding corrupt people's money from everyone else. Not exactly the most honest way of achieving a balanced budget.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoEnglishmen do that too (Post-soviet oligarchs) but it doesn't help them that much.
- nirnira 13y agoMaybe someone could do a startup to teach the Swiss how to paragraph break...
- kyboren 13y agoI moved from California to Lausanne and I highly recommend it. Quality of life is truly outstanding, and the high level of infrastructure development makes living here very convenient. The biggest problem is, as the article gently suggests, housing, which is almost impossible for foreigners to find (even with asset sheets in the hundreds of thousands of USD). Affordable housing is essentially nonexistent. Every now and then voter initiatives crop up to change the situation (remove building restrictions, reduce bureaucracy, etc.), but the problem only seems to get worse. Fortunately, an all-Switzerland unlimited travel card is only ~$4k/year for adults and ~$3k/year for <25yo's. Given the reliability and extensive reach of the public transport network here, it's definitely possible (and even fairly regular) to live in somewhat 'remote' villages and towns and still commute to work in <1hr. It's pretty cool to have the ability to live in, say, Saint-Maurice (with Bronze Age roots) and still be in the door at work within 1h15m. This is made more palatable by the extensive fiber network available in Switzerland: multiple providers are now offering 1Gb/s connections in Lausanne proper, and the reach continues to expand. Some more-remote locations are still only served by the Swisscom state pseudomonopoly, but service is usually still reasonably cheap and line rates still reasonably high. The mobile offerings here offer real competition, and along with the small size of the market, make cell service cheap and fast. Finally, EPFL itself is highly ranked and has some top talent, not only in faculty (among others, includes Arjen Lenstra, Martin Odersky, Ed Bugnion, George Candea, and Katerina Argyraki), but also in PhD and MS students. EPFL also has regular workshops for entrepreneurship and actively encourages commercialization. There's a lot of uncertainty about the new immigration mandate, which will almost certainly hurt Switzerland's attractiveness to entrepreneurs, but the ETH/EPF domain will probably not be affected; if you're a prospective graduate student interested in entrepreneurship, EPFL is definitely worth a look!
- cyphunk 13y agocommute >1h is one of the main reasons most move away from the valley. I agree though, moving away from the US is a breath of fresh air on living standards when it comes to culture and public transport. But you can pick other cities and countries to get this. Cities that have comparable burgeoning tech scenes of their own. Berlin comes to mind. All the scrappy push of a high tech culture without all the fascist government baggage of say a US, CH or Israel.