3 ms·
We don't actually know the 2 Wired writers were relying on Wikipedia or the version floating around the Internet. They might've gotten it straight from Karpels
by gwern 13y ago
We don't actually know the 2 Wired writers were relying on Wikipedia or the version floating around the Internet. They might've gotten it straight from Karpels or McCaleb or a Mtgox staffer or someone, and just not given the source for it in their article. If going to McCaleb didn't work, my next step would be contacting them to learn their source: if they said they got it from Wikipedia or didn't know, then it'd discredit the article as a source for that particular assertion and the claim could at least be deleted & doubt cast on any other RSes asserting the claim without clear rationale.
- bjourne 13y agoI am not a Wikipedia rules lawyer, but my understanding is that Wikipedia forbids original research. So even if you contact McCaleb and get the true answer from him, Wired's statement still stands because your research isn't admissible. The question has come up before in historical articles where someones secondary source is directly contradicted by some editor with direct access to the archive files.
- gwern 13y agoFor statements by involved people, AFAIK we already have procedures for handling correspondence; I can forward the emails to OTRS and we cite the ticket as our ref. Same way as we handle copyright grants.