3 ms·
> The GNU/FSF mindset is one of "You're either with us or against us" - but over here in the real world, things are not so black and white. That isn't in the l
by bjourne 13y ago
> The GNU/FSF mindset is one of "You're either with us or against us" - but over here in the real world, things are not so black and white.
That isn't in the least true. You should be very careful when trying to decode someones mindset because now you are putting words in someones mouth that never was there in the first place.
- jebblue 13y agoWell I Googl'ed: gnu fsf "you're either with us or against us" And it turns out that the idea shows up more than once. So it must be at least believed by some to be true. That includes this interesting post on Slashdot from 2001: http://interviews.slashdot.org/story/01/12/13/0242205/miguel-de-icaza-interview-on-msdn http://interviews.slashdot.org/story/01/12/13/0242205/miguel... In particular, a comment by ukryule seems especially applicable: "Taken in the spirit intended. I accept that the GNU principles are quite clearly defined - but is it really the case that "you're either with us or against us"? The original post was asking about Ximian "abandoning it's GNU values" - to which I think pointing out the open-source work it is doing is a perfectly valid response (it shows that the company at least has common ground with GNU). To be fair, I don't know if Ximian (the company) ever supported GNU values ... but if they continue to spend say 80% of their time on GPL'd sw and the other 20% on prorietory sw does this imply they do or don't support GNU values? "
- bjourne 13y agoThis must be the most intellectually dishonest comment I've read in a while. Either find someone from FSF who's written what you're claiming or this discussion is over. Finding unrelated people who feels something about the FSF's position and quoting that.. is just silly.
- jebblue 13y agoYou must be confused. I'm not claiming anything at all. I'm saying Google something and I'm saying someone wrote something 13 years ago. Any conclusions you draw are your own.
- dllthomas 13y agoI don't think anyone was arguing that the FSF being all-or-nothing, us-and-them, with-us-or-against-us was not a prevalent meme amongst their detractors. It long has been. The question was whether it is an accurate description of their positions.
- efuquen 13y agoI don't thinks words are being put into anyone's mouth, what was said was quite clear: > while Git is made by anti-GNU people who do not believe in free software As stated in above comments I would find it hard to believe Linus would not say that GNU is a valuable asset or software built strictly promoting GNU/FSF principles is bad ... but he's been labeled as anti-GNU for writing software that has a more permissible license. I don't see how this could be an even more "with us or against us" attitude. You could argue the above statement is an overgeneralization of what the OP said to the whole movement. But there are plenty of thing that prominent individuals, who work on GNU and represent the FSF, have said that would support this attitude.
- belorn 13y ago> but he's been labeled as anti-GNU for writing software that has a more permissible license No. he has been labeled as anti-gnu because of torvalds own statement like: "So I'm pretty well-known for not exactly being a huge fan of the FSF and Richard Stallman" "Linux from the very beginning was not about the FSF ideals." I would not directly call it anti-gnu, but neither is he friendly. He can also not be directly called truly neutral given the number of negative comments he has made about projects and work.
- Karunamon 13y agoI don't like the FSF or Stallman's ideals myself (I find them dogmatic, unrealistic, and probably a bunch of other negative adjectives) but I cannot deny they are a net positive influence on the world. I'm also annoyed because that very dogmatism weakens their very positive message.
- belorn 13y agoI have a hard time seeing how the world would work if people did not strive to achieve their goals. Take a for-profit company. Their goal is to make money. If I ask them to compromise on this and stop earning money, they get very dogmatic about it and completely refuse. If I ask a politician to start promoting a competitor, he will also dogmatic refuse. I can not even get him to compromise. I offer him nice bribe money, and he should accept it and step down. What I am trying to say is that dogma and compromises are not the black and white, good and evil. Dogma is required to make the world work, and compromises are only good when it doesn't interfere too much with it.