3 ms·
That still doesn't wash. It is quite possible to believe that the GNU project and what's associated with it (FSF) is a net positive while disagreeing with some
by Karunamon 13y ago
That still doesn't wash. It is quite possible to believe that the GNU project and what's associated with it (FSF) is a net positive while disagreeing with some of the actions of its founders or boosters, or some of their ideology.
The GNU/FSF mindset is one of "You're either with us or against us" - but over here in the real world, things are not so black and white.
- dllthomas 13y ago"That still doesn't wash. It is quite possible to believe that the GNU project and what's associated with it (FSF) is a net positive while disagreeing with some of the actions of its founders or boosters, or some of their ideology." A fair point. Picking licenses that explicitly forbid incorporation of your code in modern GNU projects is a little more than that, though. 'The GNU/FSF mindset is one of "You're either with us or against us"' I don't think that's quite as true as you think it is.
- Karunamon 13y agoI'd love to be proven wrong on this. Considering that their figurehead regards closed source software as unambiguously evil, I don't see many other ways to interpret their behvaior. But: >Picking licenses that explicitly forbid incorporation of your code in modern GNU projects By GNU fiat and nothing more. Some of us would rather code than get involved in tiresome political disputes. (See also the BSD class of licenses)
- dllthomas 13y ago"I'd love to be proven wrong on this. Considering that their figurehead regards closed source software as unambiguously evil, I don't see many other ways to interpret their behvaior." Assuming (with confidence) that you mean RMS, he regards it as evil but my understanding is that his framework for making the assertion is more consequentialist than his detractors believe. With "evil" usually used in more deontological frameworks, I think the confusion is understandable but also understand his not wanting to give up the forcefulness implied by the term (we see time and again that people seem to underweight the risks implied by giving up their rights); I'm not sure if it's a mistake or not. "By GNU fiat and nothing more. Some of us would rather code than get involved in tiresome political disputes. (See also the BSD class of licenses)" No, by technicality of the licenses. It is not possible to write a license that 1) adds more restrictions, and 2) is compatible with GPLv2. 1) was deemed necessary because of what were seen as loopholes in GPLv2 - this may be construed as choice but "fiat" implies an arbitrariness that was not present. If instead Git was released under "GPLv2 or later", that code could be used more broadly - which is usually the rallying cry behind those endorsing more permissive licenses. It would still be entirely possible to move code from the work to GPLv2-only licensed projects.
- teacup50 13y ago> No, by technicality of the licenses ... This teacup tempest is entirely of GNU's own making. It's nobody else's fault that their licenses are so onerous that they can't even keep them compatible with later revisions they themselves produce.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dllthomas 13y agoThis is bullshit rhetorical sophistry, and I'm pretty sure you know it. Choosing an incompatible license is the fault of the person who chose the license. The FSF made a mistake in not building "... or any later version" into the GPLv2; they acknowledge this. They've been recommending for some time - since long before the start of the Git project - that projects interested in being GPLv2 compatible include "... or any later version." Imagine it was a piece of software with a bug. There's a patched version, it's been broadly announced that there was a bug and there is a fix. You ignore that and use the buggy version. Whose fault is it when you trip over the bug? Claiming it is "entirely of [the programmer]'s own making" is absurd.
- teacup50 13y ago> This is bullshit rhetorical sophistry, and I'm pretty sure you know it. No, I don't know it. The GNU's license absolutism is what got them into this mess in the first place. It's inherent in their aims. > Imagine it was a piece of software with a bug. Imagine that it's a piece of software with a new UX direction not everyone agrees with.
- dllthomas 13y ago"No, I don't know it. The GNU's license absolutism is what got them into this mess in the first place. It's inherent in their aims." Dismantling of copyright and a replacement with a requirement ensuring the freedoms the FSF cares about would thrill them, and not produce this license-incompatibility mess. It is plain, therefore, that it is not at all inherent to their aims. It may be inherent to this particular strategy - but again, license compatibility is something they've been looking at explicitly since making the mistake with GPLv2. "Imagine that it's a piece of software with a new UX direction not everyone agrees with." If the criticism was "They did not use GPLv3", that might be a more reasonable analogy than mine. The criticism was they used GPLv2 when they could have used GPLv2+. It's like using the buggy version specifically because others can't use the new UX with it (even though I can still use my old UX with the fixed version). Characterizing that as a move in opposition to those that like the new UX is the only reasonable characterization, absent other overriding factors (back out of metaphor, the only possible reason I could see is a need to use a lot of GPLv2 code in Git - someone else would have to speak to whether that is reality).
- bjourne 13y ago> The GNU/FSF mindset is one of "You're either with us or against us" - but over here in the real world, things are not so black and white. That isn't in the least true. You should be very careful when trying to decode someones mindset because now you are putting words in someones mouth that never was there in the first place.
- jebblue 13y agoWell I Googl'ed: gnu fsf "you're either with us or against us" And it turns out that the idea shows up more than once. So it must be at least believed by some to be true. That includes this interesting post on Slashdot from 2001: http://interviews.slashdot.org/story/01/12/13/0242205/miguel-de-icaza-interview-on-msdn http://interviews.slashdot.org/story/01/12/13/0242205/miguel... In particular, a comment by ukryule seems especially applicable: "Taken in the spirit intended. I accept that the GNU principles are quite clearly defined - but is it really the case that "you're either with us or against us"? The original post was asking about Ximian "abandoning it's GNU values" - to which I think pointing out the open-source work it is doing is a perfectly valid response (it shows that the company at least has common ground with GNU). To be fair, I don't know if Ximian (the company) ever supported GNU values ... but if they continue to spend say 80% of their time on GPL'd sw and the other 20% on prorietory sw does this imply they do or don't support GNU values? "
- bjourne 13y agoThis must be the most intellectually dishonest comment I've read in a while. Either find someone from FSF who's written what you're claiming or this discussion is over. Finding unrelated people who feels something about the FSF's position and quoting that.. is just silly.
- jebblue 13y agoYou must be confused. I'm not claiming anything at all. I'm saying Google something and I'm saying someone wrote something 13 years ago. Any conclusions you draw are your own.