5 ms·
Not agreeing with the FSF's rather dogmatic stances does not make you "anti-free-software". Having no problem with closed source does not make you "anti-free-so
by Karunamon 13y ago
Not agreeing with the FSF's rather dogmatic stances does not make you "anti-free-software". Having no problem with closed source does not make you "anti-free-software".
(Except in the eyes of zealots, but who cares about them?)
- belorn 13y ago> Having no problem with closed source does not make you "anti-free-software". While true, its a bit odd of a statement. The following statements are also equally true: Having no problem with deforestation does not make you "anti-environmentalist". Having no problem with Ku Klux Klan members does not make you "anti-tolerance". Having no problem with murder and theft does not make you "anti-government". Except... if you are helping others in deforestation, the environmentalism movement will dislike you. If you are helping the Ku Klux Klan, the tolerance movement will dislike you. If you are helping murders, the government will lock you in. So why do you label FSF as zealots for disliking actions that helps those that want to threaten users with lawsuits and prevent new versions of software for being used, shared or modified?
- Karunamon 13y ago>So why do you label FSF as zealots for disliking actions that helps those that want to threaten users with lawsuits Without even getting into the broken-ness of your analogies, being anti-DRM and anti-patent-abuse and so on is one thing. Calling someone evil because they don't publish the source of their app is quite another. According to their dogma, if I write a program and don't release the source code, I have perpetrated some horrible thing on the world. Regardless of any other interaction I might have with a user of my app. Pardon my French, but that's fucking idiotic. And even if I do release the source, I'm in the wrong if I don't release it under their pet license of choice. (Though not exactly "evil".) What if my goal is to just see my code in use, not get embroiled in political battles? BSD is a de-facto more permissive license. What if I don't care if some corporation comes along and takes my code and releases a product based on it? Cool! I've helped the world somehow! And people who want to use my code don't have to get involved in GPL politics and drama! My problem with the FSF is that they assume they are Right, their stance is Right, and anyone who disagrees or dissents is Wrong. Hence dogma. I know religions with more ideological tolerance.
- belorn 13y ago> What if I don't care if some corporation comes along and takes my code and releases a product based on it? Cool! I've helped the world somehow! Say you developed a program that keep tracks of group of people. The Ku Klux Klan use it to track down black people, and the anti-tolerance movement use it to track Ku Klux Klan. You helped the world and the anti-tolerance movement should be happy right? If they would prefer that the tool could not be used by the Ku Klux Klan, then they are evil zealots with no ideological tolerance. Pardon my French too, but that's is fucking idiotic. > And people who want to use my code don't have to get involved in GPL politics and drama! That is a very dishonest statement. People can use Debian without becoming involved with politics and drama. I will state fact-less that most people who use GPL have not becoming involved with politics and drama. > I know religions with more ideological tolerance. Like BSD proponents I suppose? You own comment stated BSD as the right choice and anyone who disagrees is wrong. Maybe instead of preaching tolerance, you practice tolerance of people that disagree with you. Is it not more tolerant behavior avoid derogatory terms?
- Karunamon 13y ago>Say you developed a program that keep tracks of group of people. The Ku Klux Klan use it to track down black people, and the anti-tolerance movement use it to track Ku Klux Klan. Stop it. You're basically engaging in a not-hitler version of Godwin's Law. And it's not even relevant, since the GPL is only about source code, not about whatever that code is used for. In your completely arbitrary and fucked up example, as long as the KKK released the source code to their tracking app, the GPL has nothing to say. >You own comment stated BSD as the right choice and anyone who disagrees is wrong. No, I said BSD is a de-facto more permissive license. It objectively has fewer restrictions on a developer than the GPL. Read what I said, not what you want me to have said, please.
- belorn 13y agoWhat you said was: > BSD is a de-facto more permissive license. ... And people who want to use my code don't have to get involved in GPL politics and drama! So yes, you statement was an "BSD as the right choice, GPL is the wrong choice". If you actually want to be tolerant of people right to license what they want, you should not badmouth their choices when they don't pick the same as you. > as long as the KKK released the source code to their tracking app, the GPL has nothing to say. I have said nothing about the license. I have said that the anti-tolerance movement would have something to say when that program helps KKK. I also said that it is an understandable reaction from the anti-tolerance movement. They are allowed to be both thankful for the help they got, and scornful about the fact that it is helping KKK. This is the same complain when FSF dislike when proprietarization is made easier by other peoples license choices. They are thankful for the help, and also scornful about the fact that it makes their goal harder to achieve. If you don't find that relevant because "its a license" or because of godwin, then that is up to you.
- mdellabitta 13y agoI guess part of the issue is that Stallman came up with "Free Software," so there's obviously a version of the meaning of the term which is entirely up to Stallman. If you agree there's a wider meaning of the term, then it's up to context whether someone's making a no true Scotsman argument or rationalizing the behavior of an antagonist. Just pointing this out, because you might as well be arguing the meta-point about there being a cathedral of the meaning of "Free Software," or a bazaar. Hah.
- dllthomas 13y agoWhat was stated was "anti-GNU". Decoupling GNU from the FSF is weird.
- Karunamon 13y agoThat still doesn't wash. It is quite possible to believe that the GNU project and what's associated with it (FSF) is a net positive while disagreeing with some of the actions of its founders or boosters, or some of their ideology. The GNU/FSF mindset is one of "You're either with us or against us" - but over here in the real world, things are not so black and white.
- dllthomas 13y ago"That still doesn't wash. It is quite possible to believe that the GNU project and what's associated with it (FSF) is a net positive while disagreeing with some of the actions of its founders or boosters, or some of their ideology." A fair point. Picking licenses that explicitly forbid incorporation of your code in modern GNU projects is a little more than that, though. 'The GNU/FSF mindset is one of "You're either with us or against us"' I don't think that's quite as true as you think it is.
- Karunamon 13y agoI'd love to be proven wrong on this. Considering that their figurehead regards closed source software as unambiguously evil, I don't see many other ways to interpret their behvaior. But: >Picking licenses that explicitly forbid incorporation of your code in modern GNU projects By GNU fiat and nothing more. Some of us would rather code than get involved in tiresome political disputes. (See also the BSD class of licenses)
- dllthomas 13y ago"I'd love to be proven wrong on this. Considering that their figurehead regards closed source software as unambiguously evil, I don't see many other ways to interpret their behvaior." Assuming (with confidence) that you mean RMS, he regards it as evil but my understanding is that his framework for making the assertion is more consequentialist than his detractors believe. With "evil" usually used in more deontological frameworks, I think the confusion is understandable but also understand his not wanting to give up the forcefulness implied by the term (we see time and again that people seem to underweight the risks implied by giving up their rights); I'm not sure if it's a mistake or not. "By GNU fiat and nothing more. Some of us would rather code than get involved in tiresome political disputes. (See also the BSD class of licenses)" No, by technicality of the licenses. It is not possible to write a license that 1) adds more restrictions, and 2) is compatible with GPLv2. 1) was deemed necessary because of what were seen as loopholes in GPLv2 - this may be construed as choice but "fiat" implies an arbitrariness that was not present. If instead Git was released under "GPLv2 or later", that code could be used more broadly - which is usually the rallying cry behind those endorsing more permissive licenses. It would still be entirely possible to move code from the work to GPLv2-only licensed projects.
- bobx11 13y agoAgreeing with Karunamon completely, it's the with-us-or-against-us attitude that makes people not want to work with GNU people... they can feel like the PETA of software.