3 ms·
The original title reflected the actual point of the article, but the mods have changed it. It's captured in the last sentence: [A]ssume that bad technica
by ColinWright 13y ago
The original title reflected the actual point of the article, but the mods have changed it. It's captured in the last sentence:
[A]ssume that bad technical decisions are made
rationally, for reasons that are not apparent.
I suppose changing the title from informative to non-informative is a decision being made rationally for reasons that are not apparent.
To the moderators:
I understand why you sometimes change the titles on submissions, setting them to the original title on the source page. I get it, I really do. But this article really, really isn't about the stadiometer, and while it's true that you've changed it to the original title on the source page, it is deeply misleading, and the extent to which it's not misleading, it's uninformative.
Please, please, can you sort this out? The title I carefully provided was intended to get to the intent and content of the item, and I feel that it was much, much more informative. You are removing information, and that feels like a really bad thing.
It can't be a 'bot doing the change, because it would've happened sooner, so there must be a human looking at this and making the decision to change it. They are already expending brain-power on the task, they are already looking at the submission, why not actually make a decision, rather than acting in a purely mechanical fashion?
Case in point, consider this submission:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7245505 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7245505
You haven't changed the title on that. Why not? Because the title is "pub". If you change the informative title on this post to one that's non-informative, why not change the title on that one?
Someone, somewhere, is making decisions already. For the sake of making HN a better place, please consider a better process for doing so.
- planckscnst 13y agoYes, a thousand times! A title exists in a context. The context of the original medium is completely different than a list of articles on HN. For instance, people who subscribe to an author's blog typically know the author's voice and typical subject matter, whereas people who see a title in a long list of possibly interesting content pieces do not have that context, so the original title does not communicate to those what the author was intending to communicate. There must be a better solution than blindly reverting every title.
- triplesec 13y agoFor some reason it seems to be a simple posting rule in HN and mods like to do this. Yet it's not always adhered to. Confusing!