4 ms·
The minimum evidence that we are in fact in a simulation would be observing a violation of physics. Until then, all is speculation.
by dsr_ 13y ago
The minimum evidence that we are in fact in a simulation would be observing a violation of physics.
Until then, all is speculation.
- thenmar 13y agothat doesn't really make any sense though
- solipsism 13y agoIt would be a leap of logic to assert that we're in a simulation after observing a violation of physics. The first possibility we'd have to consider is that our understanding of physics is flawed. After that consideration (or maybe as a part of that consideration, depending on how you look at it), we'd have to consider the possibility that the laws of physics are not constant. But why would we jump immediately to the universe being a simulation?
- lutusp 13y ago> The minimum evidence that we are in fact in a simulation would be observing a violation of physics. Not at all. A "violation of physics", by which I assume you mean a discrepancy between our picture of the universe and the real universe as revealed in experiment, only tells us that our model is wrong. There have been any number of "violations of physics" over the decades. We believed that a luminiferous ether served as a medium for light waves -- wrong. We believed that neutrinos didn't have mass -- wrong. We believed that all mass/energy was accounted for by the descriptions in the Standard Model -- very wrong (only 4% is so described, the rest is dark matter and dark energy, with no present explanation). The simplest explanation for these discrepancies, consistent with lex parsimoniae or "Occam's razor" is that our model isn't good enough and needs revision, not that the universe is a simulation. It's equally logical (and not very logical at all) to argue that a perfectly running universe, with no anomalies, would constitute evidence for a simulation, on the ground that any self-respecting superbeing able to craft an entire universe, would surely test his code before launching it.
- gfodor 13y agoWhen someone posts something like this, do they honestly believe everyone else having this debate, including serious physicists, are just stupid because they can't see the brilliant insight they have posted?
- lutusp 13y agoIt's a typical post by someone whose knowledge of physics is limited to the content of the Discovery Channel, whose physics scripts are worded in just this way.
- Helianthus 13y agoOh, get over yourselves, both of you. He's just starting a conversation, and while I wouldn't advocate handing out participation ribbons, you're just trashing someone that had a thought and expressed it--you and gfodor are buddying up to one another over how worthless that thought is. Spare us your revelry. I'm as big a fan as a dirty flame war as anyone. I find complaints over HN's critical culture to be tiring and self-defeating. But if you're going to be negative, don't give each other high fives about it. Edit: I suppose this is directed more at you, lutusp, because gfodor seems to be posting criticism in earnest.
- lutusp 13y agoI posted what I did so nontechnical readers wouldn't be misled. Would you object if I similarly addressed someone who claimed that evolution must be wrong because it's not in the Bible? > ... you're just trashing someone that had a thought and expressed it ... Indeed, that's what I did, but it was because of what was expressed, not the fact of its expression. Surely it has by now occurred to you that you're defending this person's right to say whatever he chooses, while denying me the same right? Or did that escape your attention? > Oh, get over yourselves, both of you. Under the circumstances, it's time for you to get over yourself. The OP's post, and my reply, are perfectly symmetrical -- one demands the other.
- 13y ago
- logicallee 13y agoIt is not possible to observe a violation of physics, because physics is defined as whatever you observe. For real.