4 ms·
It's always amazing how much hate exercise gets on the internet. The majority of the comments on here are - well this or that should count as exercise not actua
by AndrewKemendo 13y ago
It's always amazing how much hate exercise gets on the internet. The majority of the comments on here are - well this or that should count as exercise not actually having to go and do some specific "exercise" training.
As someone who did not used to like to exercise and now do I think it's just a whole wad of cognitive dissonance for people who largely are out of shape (by the way that /= fat) and don't want to feel like they should spend time doing specific body improving exercises.
- Dewie 13y agoReally? Every time I see exercise brought up on HN, there are no shortage of people who are praising how exercise have changed their life. And if people are talking about leading a balanced and happy life, having an active life/exercising definitely gets brought up. It doesn't even have to be related for someone to bring it up: "Your dog died? I'm sorry about that. You should try exercising, that usually cheers me up."
- null_ptr 13y agoSome people plain don't like being told they could do things better, it's a matter of ego. You could argue that this negative reaction is inflated by the hyper-social internet culture we're all swimming in these days, where it's easy to compare each facet of your life to the collective's best. Not to mention that a lot of people associate exercise with body image, and that comes with its own boatload of issues.
- beachstartup 13y agoit's the same mental rut as people stuck in a terrible dead-end job, or in abusive / shitty relationships. this is not a value judgment on what type of job/relationship is good; these people are suffering. some are highly paid, or have the outward appearances of a good relationship. they have self-imposed a set of beliefs, a system of beliefs built up through unfortunate circumstances that have no bearing on wider reality, that limit their ability to improve their circumstances. it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. their mind will do all sorts of logical gymnastics to avoid admitting the truth or taking action. you can see it in this thread. people just make things up out of thin air, convinced of their truth. i was tempted to reply to a couple but then i saw your comment. it's like living in the matrix or something. it's so hard to explain because smart people can fall for it too. to this day, i find myself slipping into these self-defeating thought cycles every once in a while. maybe it's some kind of stockholm syndrome.
- pjc50 13y agoVictim-blaming AND false consciousness! Great way of disclaiming any responsibility for helping anyone in that situation.
- beachstartup 13y ago> disclaiming any responsibility it's not my responsibility to offer to help strangers unsolicited. in fact, it's kind of rude.
- pjc50 13y agoA lot of people associate exercise with pain, or the misery of compulsory sport at school (which often comes with a side order of sanctioned bullying and abuse).
- beachstartup 13y agohold on, let's back up a step. getting up and walking around a few times a week shouldn't be associated with pain or bullying or abuse. if it is, you are almost certainly suffering from a mental illness (for able-bodied people, obviously). this is not a troll. please take a step back and realize that 'normal' people should not have a problem with going outside for a walk. please come back into reality.
- MisterBastahrd 13y agoPainful? No. Boring? Absolutely. I think half the problem with exercise as adults is that there's little to no mental stimulation involved in the process (provided one isn't playing a sport), and modern culture has inundated us with so much noise that many don't know how to handle a prolonged period where they aren't working and aren't entertained.
- nisa 13y agoYou've already mentioned the solution: Play a sport!
- sz4kerto 13y agoThat's exactly one good reason to do it.
- eric_the_read 13y agoI absolutely agree. It was only after I started listening to podcasts that I stopped finding running so boring. Even music I find exciting wasn't interesting enough.
- pjc50 13y agoThis is back to "what counts as exercise"; I was referring to team sport and gym environment and running. Not "going outside for a walk", which is in the category of the parent post of "things people want to count as exercise that don't really".
- cgag 13y agoI'm definitely with you that all the people who want super easy activities to count as exercise are speaking from cognitive dissonance. I will say however that I've been lifting fairly regularly for a decent amount of time and I still see it as tedious.
- venomsnake 13y agoIts because of the way exercise is sold - I have found one really awesome benefit of resistance training that no one ever talks about - insanely increased libido. If you are out of shape and just try a few deadlifts you will see the difference and will have hard time staying away from the gym.