3 ms·
Just a couple of follow-ups. I see your points but history doesn't agree. People adapt or die, and sometimes adapt and die. Looking at it in the 'small' (which
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
Just a couple of follow-ups. I see your points but history doesn't agree. People adapt or die, and sometimes adapt and die. Looking at it in the 'small' (which is on an individual anecdote level) vs looking at it in the 'large' which is on a population cohort level. When there are large industrial changes there are employment shifts. That displaces some workers, creates new opportunities which are filled by new workers. After one or two generations of stability the process flattens out.
> Look at all these students with $200k debt.
This gets thrown around a lot. But it is a red herring. You need to drill down to find students who paid $200K for a worthless education, yes there are some, are they a material subset of all students? No. Look at all the people who were put into mortgages they couldn't afford because the rules were changed to incentivize that. That about pulled down the global financial system (we're still not quite done with that mistake). There is certainly a social justice issue with student debt, providing loans to students to get degrees that are unmarketable. But the 'fix' is to get rid of the debt discharge protection that student loans currently have. Allow the students to declare bankruptcy and dump the obligation, and guess what nobody will loan students $200K to get a fine arts degree. Is that a problem ? I don't know. For schools? Yes, they are already figuring out that they can't sell a diploma for an arbitrary price any more.