6 ms·
Some people talk about "Guaranteed Minimum Income" as a conditional income guarantee, as opposed to an unconditional "Basic Income" I don't feel strongly (eith
by ForHackernews 13y ago
Some people talk about "Guaranteed Minimum Income" as a conditional income guarantee, as opposed to an unconditional "Basic Income"
I don't feel strongly (either approach would be an improvement over the status quo), but I suppose I mildly agree with you. I think human beings need to have some Work to feel like their lives have meaning. Even if we made GMI conditional on 10 hours a week of charity volunteering, that could have positive mental health outcomes.
- vdaniuk 13y agoDo you have any citations that mandatory charity work are beneficial for the psychological condition? Also are there data about negative or positive externalities of forced charity work?
- Havoc 13y ago>Do you have any citations that mandatory charity work are beneficial for the psychological condition? You raise a valid point. At first I thought "don't be stupid...obviously its beneficial". Looking at that word "mandatory" in your question though I'm no longer confident in my initial instinct....
- ForHackernews 13y agoIn our hypothetical scenario, it's not "mandatory"--it's freely available. If you already have some other highly paid job, great. If not, there's always the option of doing the volunteer work in exchange for the minimum income from the government. There would probably also need to be some kind of exemption for people with physical or mental disabilities.
- vdaniuk 13y agoExemptions and regulations add to the administrative overheads. Monitoring and enforcing quality of volunteer work is a large overhead, too. The efficiency of basic income lies in its extreme simplicity. However, the details of basic income-like schemes may be irrelevant. Basic income and its mutations are possible when most household products are basically done by robots. It is possible basic income will grow at 25-50% YoY rate and that growth indicator is only thing that matters.
- ForHackernews 13y agoLike I said, I'm not really invested in basic income vs guaranteed minimum income. You could have a volunteer work "requirement" that was only enforced by social convention. If it was seen as dishonest/lazy to take the income without giving back to your community in any way, that would probably spur some social good without the inefficiency of a heavy-handed enforcement mechanism.
- dllthomas 13y agoI think basic income with a social norm of "making sure you're doing some good for someone" is the way to go.
- Havoc 13y ago> The efficiency of basic income lies in its extreme simplicity. Fair enough. I find it difficult to accept a system that doesn't grant a powerful advantage to a person with a significant physical/mental disability though. Equal basic income for all does not seem fair in that context. Also...this is more me thinking out loud than attacking anyone.
- vdaniuk 13y agoI get what you are saying, but what about if we optimize not for equality but for happiness. Redistribution of value is a zero-sum game, while non-material value as happiness is not. I was thinking how equality movemen failed to produced social change in short time as world is extremely unbalanced. I think post-scarcity economy will bring new solutions and new social contracts.
- Havoc 13y ago>what about if we optimize not for equality but for happiness. Again, you make a valid point. Let me stop the debate right here though. We're venturing into philosophical territory here...the kind more suited to 5000 word essays than HN posts. One thing we can debate however: >post-scarcity economy I find this notion decidedly problematic. We've been optimizing the sht out of production for decades and yet the average family is battling to make ends meet more than ever. "post-scarcity economy"...I don't buy it...not even close.
- ForHackernews 13y agoSee my response to the other child comment, this wouldn't be a mandatory scheme. But in any case, compulsory community service as an alternative to jail time has shown promising results: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-10725163 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-10725163
- vdaniuk 13y agoIn the context of basic income compulsory of community service the alternative is forcing nothing on the person, not jail time.
- psbp 13y agoBasic income wouldn't take work away. It would assure that not working when there isn't work to do wouldn't leave people impoverished or lead to an economic collapse. It would allow people to participate in the economy and pursue productivity or creative pursuits without worrying about starving. I doubt it's coming, but I don't see its downside in a world where per capita productivity is trivial.
- dllthomas 13y ago"It would assure that not working when there isn't work to do wouldn't leave people impoverished or lead to an economic collapse." Not working, or working on figuring out how to get paid in the new environment, when what worked last year is now automated...
- Havoc 13y ago>need to have some Work to feel like their lives have meaning. Agreed. Vaguely relevant story time for 1st world crowd: In my country (South Africa) it is illegal for the public to refuel their own cars. There is dedicated staff that does nothing else all day - essentially behave like restaurant waiters but for petrol stations. Realistically the law is only in place for job creation purposes - it is by most measures unnecessary. And yet I've come to appreciate it: I don't need to leave my car. The people handling flammable liquids do this all day long & received training - much better than random McDonalds munching idiots. Credit card speedpoint gets brought to my car window, windscreen washed, tyre pressure checked etc. I end up (voluntarily) tipping 0.5 USD - a drop in the ocean. I have a million problems so a guy making my life easier there & smiling whilst doing so...I'm totally ok with carrying him on my tax/fuel bill.
- Houshalter 13y agoThere is already technology being rolled out to automate pumping gas.
- Havoc 13y agoThats the point - it could be done "easier" via self-help or automated but the law requires job creation. Us privileged people should seriously consider accepting that while it does not make economic sense, it does work from a convenience & social point of view. Both of those are powerful drivers.
- Houshalter 13y agoIt would be better just to pay people for nothing rather than requiring them to do useless work.
- Havoc 13y ago> It would be better just to pay people for nothing rather than requiring them to do useless work. You miss my point entirely. It is not useless work. Sure its not economically efficient, but on balance I'd rather have people streamline the refueling process than sit in front of a TV and collect a paycheque.