3 ms·
I can't help feeling that this is just the same story as always. Take the GIMP. It still isn't really compatible enough to be a drop-in replacement for Photosh
by Silhouette 13y ago
I can't help feeling that this is just the same story as always.
Take the GIMP. It still isn't really compatible enough to be a drop-in replacement for Photoshop. It still has limitations on basic stuff like colour handling and typography. It still has a name that sounds like a sophomore's dirty joke. If all you need is a basic image retouching application for photos on your web site, it's fine. For full professional use, it's not even close.
The same arguments applies to almost all of the "big name" FOSS competitors to dominant proprietary applications from the likes of Microsoft and Adobe: data portability isn't quite good enough, features are missing or underpowered, and usability is often inferior. They're fine as free substitutes and good enough for basics (which for many people is sufficient) but the "high" prices of the professional applications are justified in a heartbeat if you have real work to do as a power user.
What I don't understand is why FOSS continues to be dominated by cheap knock-offs in these fields. One man wrote TeX, albeit one exceptionally talented and driven man, and to this day a whole industry uses it in preference to anything else because it does what it does differently and much better than the mainstream products. There's still plenty its users would like to improve, but then that's true of Microsoft Office and Adobe Creative Suite too, and they have barely changed in years despite the vast resources available to their development teams.
In short, if the FOSS world wants to compete in the market for mainstream creative applications, it needs to start innovating and change the rules so the presumption isn't that the FOSS has to (try to) match incumbent proprietary products on their own terms. The question shouldn't be whether you can cycle between .docx and .odt without messing up your formatting or whether you can translate an AI file to an Inkscape-friendly SVG and back without losing details. The question should be why you'd want to in the first place.
- stusmall 13y ago>>One man wrote TeX, albeit one exceptionally talented and driven man, and to this day a whole industry uses it in preference to anything else because it does what it differently and much better than the mainstream product. I'm assuming that industry is academia? LaTeX was almost all I saw in university but that definitely changed once I entered industry. I don't know any professional technical writers that use it. I'm not dogging it and think its great (my resume is in LaTeX) I don't know if its comparable of the other programs (Office and CS) that you mentioned that aim for a much broader appeal. It has a market but it is a small niche one.
- Silhouette 13y agoI'm not dogging it and think its great (my resume is in LaTeX) I don't know if its comparable of the other programs (Office and CS) that you mentioned that aim for a much broader appeal. It has a market but it is a small niche one. That's true, and in a way it's part of my point. Trying to take on one-size-fits-all giants is probably not a good long-term strategy for FOSS, because the barrier to entry is prohibitively high and you drain a lot of resources (primarily enthusiastic volunteers) away from other projects they could potentially have supported instead. But pick a niche, or get a larger team together to build something more general but with a different perspective than the likes of Office and CS, and as the likes of TeX (or Sublime Text, as a more contemporary example) show, not many people can get remarkable things built.
- weland 13y agoIt's quite widely used for technical publishing in general, not necessarily in academia. Typeset equations in many high-profile publishing packages are still somewhere between abysmal and horrible, so there's still some incentive to its use. Outside that? Probably not, but there's a lot of polarization in modern typography. Much of it is either of exceptional quality that goes beyond "just" advanced typesetting, or of such a poor taste that Word suffices.
- GhotiFish 13y agoI agree in one sense. I've always held the opinion that it is a miracle Microsoft Word even works at all. It's a gigantic one tool fits all writing application that's implemented on a feature by feature basis into a mega program with thousands of clashes and interactions... and it works. It's insane, and then programmers come along and try to emulate such insanity in an open source program. It doesn't work. All that said. I feel Blender is becoming another miracle. The platform they have made is very flexible. It's compositing system has insane potential. The workflow is great and getting better, support is great and getting better. I don't know why blender isn't seeing more popularity, Maya must be F#$ing nirvana.
- Silhouette 13y agoI don't know why blender isn't seeing more popularity, Maya must be F#$ing nirvana. I can think of at least one obvious (if you work in the industry) reason for that one: Autodesk software uses FBX, and so does the workflow for many professionals, but Blender doesn't support FBX comprehensively and only added FBX import within the past year. However, if this new addition is a permanent development and free of serious legal wrangles, it could be a game-changer. I know plenty of people in the 3D modelling industry who already prefer Blender in general, but for compatibility and workflow reasons have been stuck in Autodesk world. Given the obvious cost implications but also the hassles with buying Autodesk software even if you're willing to pay, and then the treadmill of commercial training and documentation to make up for the weaknesses in the official documentation and not always great usability of the product itself, there is more incentive to jump ship in this case than for almost any other kind of software I'm familiar with.
- altero 13y agoYou could also say that new commercial applications are cheap knockoffs of older versions. Win8 is joke compared to Win7, Office 2003 is better than 20something. New Photoshop brings zero improvement except some crazy DRM. Open-source programs are at least stable. It is less likely some commercial company will flush my investment into toilet. And Photoshop is probably better than Gimp, but in other areas the winner is not that clear. For example OpenOffice versus MS Office. Or my favorite example KWin versus.... nothing.
- eitland 13y agoSeconded. Until recently I've kept a copy of oprn office/libre office around for longer documents. Until office 2010 I used to joke about word only being able to deal with up to 25 pages and less than two authors (i.e. one) Of course seasoned professionals can use Word but for general office... no. Most people didn't understand styles in Word
- Silhouette 13y agoYou could also say that new commercial applications are cheap knockoffs of older versions. We certainly don't bother with the upgrade treadmill here. We'll spend a small fortune on serious software if it has demonstrable value to us. But upgrade to a recent version of MS Office on the desktop? I suppose that's marginally more likely than us signing up to a recurring subscription for something we already bought once, where the "enhancements" mostly involve added DRM, randomly changing user interfaces, paying several times as much in practice for useful software, and cloud serv^W^Wsecurity, reliability, sustainability and privacy risks that we would never seriously consider taking. Open-source programs are at least stable. It is less likely some commercial company will flush my investment into toilet. I so wish that were true. In reality, I don't find most FOSS native applications significantly better or worse in this respect than proprietary/commercial ones. Still, both are dramatically better than most SaaS applications or magically changing software like Firefox and Chrome.