3 ms·
As much as I'm looking forward to all the shiny tech I can't help but feel anxious about the implications for humanity as a whole. e.g. Right now the poorest o
by Havoc 13y ago
As much as I'm looking forward to all the shiny tech I can't help but feel anxious about the implications for humanity as a whole.
e.g. Right now the poorest of the poor can still resort to back breaking repetitive work to survive. If the tech keeps going then soon these people will not be able to compete...at all.
Its a recipe for inequality magnified 100x & I don't see the social fabric surviving that.
- ForHackernews 13y agoSomething's going to have to give. If we don't plan for a peaceful transition, it will happen without planning, in a not-so-peaceful way. We need to start thinking about basic income sooner rather than later: http://www.bostonglobe.com/ideas/2014/02/09/should-government-pay-you-alive/aaLVJsUAc5pKh0iYTFrXpI/story.html http://www.bostonglobe.com/ideas/2014/02/09/should-governmen...
- Havoc 13y ago>basic income Personally I oppose the idea - kinda. To be more precise I would prefer a system that stacks the odds in their favour heavily rather than "free money". e.g. Give them their cash...but make them guide school kids across a dangerous road in return. i.e. Extract some (extra) social benefit from it. Makes little financial sense either way, but I'd much rather have them do the school kids thing & collect cash than sleep & collect cash.
- ForHackernews 13y agoSome people talk about "Guaranteed Minimum Income" as a conditional income guarantee, as opposed to an unconditional "Basic Income" I don't feel strongly (either approach would be an improvement over the status quo), but I suppose I mildly agree with you. I think human beings need to have some Work to feel like their lives have meaning. Even if we made GMI conditional on 10 hours a week of charity volunteering, that could have positive mental health outcomes.
- vdaniuk 13y agoDo you have any citations that mandatory charity work are beneficial for the psychological condition? Also are there data about negative or positive externalities of forced charity work?
- Havoc 13y ago>Do you have any citations that mandatory charity work are beneficial for the psychological condition? You raise a valid point. At first I thought "don't be stupid...obviously its beneficial". Looking at that word "mandatory" in your question though I'm no longer confident in my initial instinct....
- ForHackernews 13y agoIn our hypothetical scenario, it's not "mandatory"--it's freely available. If you already have some other highly paid job, great. If not, there's always the option of doing the volunteer work in exchange for the minimum income from the government. There would probably also need to be some kind of exemption for people with physical or mental disabilities.
- vdaniuk 13y agoExemptions and regulations add to the administrative overheads. Monitoring and enforcing quality of volunteer work is a large overhead, too. The efficiency of basic income lies in its extreme simplicity. However, the details of basic income-like schemes may be irrelevant. Basic income and its mutations are possible when most household products are basically done by robots. It is possible basic income will grow at 25-50% YoY rate and that growth indicator is only thing that matters.
- ForHackernews 13y agoLike I said, I'm not really invested in basic income vs guaranteed minimum income. You could have a volunteer work "requirement" that was only enforced by social convention. If it was seen as dishonest/lazy to take the income without giving back to your community in any way, that would probably spur some social good without the inefficiency of a heavy-handed enforcement mechanism.
- Phlarp 13y agoIn a less idealistic implementation of this; you end up with the TSA. And to a lesser extent the modern day "professional" military. Massive jobs program hammers, begging for nails.
- Havoc 13y agoThat is not what I meant. You speak of idealistic implementation...its not all that far fetched. Refer to my comment here for a real life working implementation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7240235 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7240235 >Massive jobs program hammers, begging for nails. Perhaps. I think you judge them unjustly though - it is certainly prone to bureaucrats sinking the scheme with BS, but I don't think it is in itself prone to sinking. As for the TSA comment - my condolences to all Americans. I don't feel its a representative example of the current debate though.
- dllthomas 13y agoMy big objection to this is that you have to pay a bunch of government bureaucrats to sit around and say what does and doesn't count. I don't think that's a worthwhile use of people's time.
- hencq 13y agoThe authors of the article actually wrote a book on this very subject (mentioned at the bottom of the article). They actually devote a lot of attention to exactly that problem, which they refer to as the bounty (gains because of new technology) and the spread (the inequality you mention).
- Havoc 13y agoThanks - I didn't see that. Might actually buy that book. As I said this is something that makes me deeply uneasy. I'm pretty relaxed about most "serious" issues...e.g. Climate change - I feel "it'll be fine & we'll make it work somehow". Looking at this problem I can't help but feel it will not be OK. And thats coming from a guy in South Africa - a society that is barely hanging on under the strain of inequality. SA is on the very edge of what the social fabric can withstand in terms of inequality & AI will cause inequality that is much worse.
- psbp 13y agoBasic income will likely be the answer.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoOk, to put my trollface on... <not serious> Plainly the best thing to do is hurry the development of machine learning algorithms for active environments, also known as AI, in order to minimize the gap of time between most of the world's people becoming unemployable and most of the world's people being made of atoms the AI can use for something else. </not serious>