10 ms·
The Dawn of the Age of Artificial Intelligence
- danso 13y agoUgh, I know this is par for course, but these kind of articles really irritate me. Especially passages like these: > People with connected smartphones or tablets anywhere in the world have access to many (if not most) of the same communication resources and information that we do while sitting in our offices at MIT. They can search the Web and browse Wikipedia. They can follow online courses, some of them taught by the best in the academic world. They can share their insights on blogs, Facebook, Twitter, and many other services, most of which are free. They can even conduct sophisticated data analyses using cloud resources such as Amazon Web Services and R, an open source application for statistics. A. What does this have to do with artificial intelligence? B. Access to technology does not equal access to ability to use that technology. I would argue that the problem isn't that people don't have access to powerful statistical processing and analytical software, it's that they don't know what to do with it, or with the plenty powerful software that has been available to them in the past decade. The parallel construction of "Everyone can now share stuff on Facebook" with "Everyone can now do statistical analyses via R and Hadoop!" is a gross error of characterization by the OP.
- upquark 13y agoSome academic types have no clue how far behind the rest of humanity is in terms of intellectual and technological readiness to use such tools. It could be an honest mistake and not a deliberate lie.
- altcognito 13y agoA. Nothing directly, it's just a comment on why progress seems to be increasing dramatically when compared to the 80's - early 90's. B. Sure.
- DanBC 13y agoSearch is an AI problem - computers have to try to return decent results. Facebook has to crop photos in an optimal way - they do a pretty good job of that. Either of those feel closer to AI than compression, which is sometimes given as another example of an AI challenge.
- mdda 13y agoCompression doesn't seem that smart on the level of 'gzip'. But one can also look at what the brain is doing when learning (and classifying stuff into conceptual clusters) as also being compression. Given the enormous theoretical 'capacity' of the brain (however defined), the compression may not be required for space reasons - but it potentially serves an interesting function in terms of understanding.
- dllthomas 13y ago"Compression doesn't seem that smart on the level of 'gzip'." If I give you a pile of text, what compression ratios would you achieve by hand?
- sentientmachine 13y agoWhat scares me the most is that by the time we have the technology to bring this artificial intelligence very close to our limbic system and subconscious mind, our computers (smartphones, desktops, tablets and other) will be so totally and thoroughly monitored, throttled, spied on, back doored, and censored, that we will be presented with the choice: 1. Refrain from getting enhanced, and suffer the consequences of limited ability and limited existence. 2. Get enhanced, and start the slow march where people aren't individuals anymore, we are drones in a collection of drones, with a queen. But hey, maybe that's the best thing ever to happen to our species, to become half and half. Half of the humans become like a hive of bees or colony of ants, and the other half sees if separate and individual free agents is able to perform better. Then the wars that come later will see which one natural selection selects.
- erichocean 13y agoIt's amazing Ender's Game was written in the 70s.
- sentientmachine 13y agoHives and colonies where the drones don't contribute to the direction are better at staying alive and brute forcing any goal, mowing down an opponent through violence, keeping the colony and hive alive against the individual interests of the drones. Whereas a collection of cooperating individuals are better at choosing the best opportunities for the individuals and advancing the cause of the interests of the drones. Cooperating individuals cause chaos, infighting and huge inefficiency in things that should be very easy, however, in doing so, each individual becomes like a mini hive/colony in and of itself. We are are the cusp of a glorious age, we may live to see the creation of a new species of human which are to humans as humans are to monkeys. All made possible through using technology to enhance all of our senses, and to provide additional resources to our own thoughts. I just might join that colony of bees. In the future, I think militaries will take this route. When you join the military and are deployed, you give up your individuality, your movements and thoughts are no longer your own.
- brianberns 13y agoHow many times now has the age of AI been heralded without it ever actually arriving?
- cryptoz 13y agoIt's arriving right now. I can speak in plain English to my smartphone (or any other language really, it knows more human languages than I do), cars drive themselves, the world's billionaires are now focused on rapid AI development, etc. There are so many things different this time around that you shouldn't be so pessimistic. "It's different this time" (it actually is though)!
- CmonDev 13y agoI am optimistic, but there were dolls capable of playing musics back in Medieval Age, I feel like e.g. Siri is one of those things.
- appledapple 13y agoThe difference to me is that the dolls capable of playing music were made up of a small set of parts compared to 15 million lines of code for Wolfram Alpha. We are way more sophisticated today.
- CmonDev 13y agoYou chose a bad example. Wolfram Alpha is like 15000 of such dolls. Not an AI in any way though.
- benched 13y agoI had legos when I was a kid. The Burj Khalifa is pretty much just like that.
- CmonDev 13y agoPretty much. It's not like it is 3d-printed, robot-assembled or "grown" in a semi-biological way.
- jotm 13y agoHey, fuck your invisible auto playing video/audio!
- michaelochurch 13y agoI feel like this article is just another aspect of the bubble. We have people on the sidelines-- intelligent people, but unaware of what the "tech" industry is actually doing-- cheering on something they hardly understand. Look, Google is a closed-allocation company. So, I believe, are Apple and Amazon and probably Facebook. Socially, we're stuck in the 1980s. If people at the 99th percentile of technical literacy are still stuck mindlessly churning tickets in closed-allocation environments-- note that basic research funding has fallen off a cliff in the past 30 years-- and raising VC is still more about playing a feudal reputation economy than anything remotely approaching excellence, then what are most of the world's 7.1 billion people going to be able to contribute to this brave new world? Nothing. They'll have no leverage, nor the resources to learn what they need to learn because they'll have to spend all their time on basic survival. The only thing that seems to await the majority, barring some unforeseen social or economic right angle (the long-term odds of which are quite high) is joblessness. We can't even deliver basic healthcare to middle-class Americans anymore, and here we have the gall to say that humanity's approaching some technotopia?
- sjg007 13y agoI agree with the healthcare sentiment. Obamacare is better than bankruptcy though. A $12k max out of pocket vs say $150k+. At least one could attempt to pay that off and maybe get some kind of Federal forgiveness vs straight out bankruptcy.
- comatose_kid 13y agoI don't understand how this seemingly random bunch of statements strung together is the top-voted comment in this thread.
- drakaal 13y agoAI is limited more by language than anything else. NLP which I do a lot of work on at http://plexinlp.com http://plexinlp.com goes a long way, but the computer doesn't have the ability to get metaphors, or sarcasm, or have any sort of "BS" detection. CoreNLP (which isn't as good as our NLP but is the "standard" only gets the parts of speech right 95% of the time, by words, but about 75% of the time by sentence. Imagine you were a waiter and you only understood 75% of sentences. You'd not last too long. But somehow we expect computers which not only are limited to 75% of sentences being "tagged" correctly, but then not having any idea about the concepts behind them. AI as we see it today is not so much "AI" as it is Computer Driven Bucketing. Build a formula that gets as many things in to pre-sorted buckets as possible. For me it isn't AI until the computer can make leaps of its own. Create a new bucket and explain why it was needed, or create a new solution that wasn't proposed by the programmer. I am working hard to bring all of that to fruition, but honestly we are a long ways off. Here are some milestones I think we will need to hit before we get to AI. Software powerful enough to convert Wikipedia (or any knowledgebase) to structured Data automatically. Query system that takes any user input and converts it to something resembling a Database query (This is what I'm working on) NPC's for Games/MMO's etc that pass a turring test with in the limits of their Virtual world. (Basically they don't have to pass for real, just as real as the DnD character a human would play) These are really "simple" milestones that are the step before we see true AI start to work.
- hershel 13y agoBut why do we need to judge ai by our language? if were dealing with data and images, machine learning does do impressive things,including things that if were done by researchers would have certainly gotten them a place inside respectable academic journals. For example ,a machine learning algorithm devised a new internet protocol that doubles the network capacity over best known methods.Another famous machine learning system understood own it's own how to classify images what belongs to the bucket of "cat" and many other object types. Why isn't this enough to be considered intelligent?
- drakaal 13y agoBecause those aren't Intelligent, they are just "handy". Sorting doesn't require intelligence. You have X number of attributes and using them you do your best to get as many things in to "Like" buckets as possible. Discovering new attributes is the start of intelligence. Discovering new buckets could be intelligence. If the machine gets 100k pictures and can sort them in to Cat vs No Cat, and then suggests a new set of classification "Indoors vs outdoors" using attributes the developer didn't pre-identify that would be intelligence.
- Havoc 13y agoAs much as I'm looking forward to all the shiny tech I can't help but feel anxious about the implications for humanity as a whole. e.g. Right now the poorest of the poor can still resort to back breaking repetitive work to survive. If the tech keeps going then soon these people will not be able to compete...at all. Its a recipe for inequality magnified 100x & I don't see the social fabric surviving that.
- ForHackernews 13y agoSomething's going to have to give. If we don't plan for a peaceful transition, it will happen without planning, in a not-so-peaceful way. We need to start thinking about basic income sooner rather than later: http://www.bostonglobe.com/ideas/2014/02/09/should-government-pay-you-alive/aaLVJsUAc5pKh0iYTFrXpI/story.html http://www.bostonglobe.com/ideas/2014/02/09/should-governmen...
- Havoc 13y ago>basic income Personally I oppose the idea - kinda. To be more precise I would prefer a system that stacks the odds in their favour heavily rather than "free money". e.g. Give them their cash...but make them guide school kids across a dangerous road in return. i.e. Extract some (extra) social benefit from it. Makes little financial sense either way, but I'd much rather have them do the school kids thing & collect cash than sleep & collect cash.
- ForHackernews 13y agoSome people talk about "Guaranteed Minimum Income" as a conditional income guarantee, as opposed to an unconditional "Basic Income" I don't feel strongly (either approach would be an improvement over the status quo), but I suppose I mildly agree with you. I think human beings need to have some Work to feel like their lives have meaning. Even if we made GMI conditional on 10 hours a week of charity volunteering, that could have positive mental health outcomes.
- 13y ago
- bcantrill 13y agoThe thing that's so aggravating about this article is what is so aggravating about AI: the arrogant comparison of software systems to true intelligence. The examples cited by the article are emphatically not "intelligence" as we understand it: Siri isn't, Watson isn't, Google's self-driving cars aren't. They represent algorithms (clever, in many cases) executed by a stored-program computer -- or many. They take advantage of what computers are really good at: the ability to perfectly execute endless streams of simple instructions with astonishing speed; the ability to access vast quantities of data with zero error; and the ability to reliably transmit that data to one another. These innovations also reflect the fundamental brittleness of the machines that implement them: the machines can only do exactly what they're told -- and if they're told to do the wrong thing, they will gladly do it. The intelligence, then, is purely in the humans that are programming and engineering the thing -- not the thing itself. I understand that this distinction is entirely lost on those who have no understanding of what's behind the curtain -- but we do a broader disservice when we pretend that our adept sleight of hand is, in fact, magic. And my apologies for just speaking the truths that many here already know; over my decades in computer science, I have tried to hold my tongue whenever the AI cultists scream at passers-by that the singularity is near -- but every now and again I must scream back for my own sanity.
- rm445 13y agoSome of us believe that general intelligence is possible in (complex) software on a (powerful) stored-program computer. As in, we don't know how to write it yet but it doesn't require weird quantum effects. The processors are just doing the very simple operations they are told to, very fast, but the intelligence arises from the complexity of the system. However I quite agree that the cheerleaders for AI frequently do us all a disservice by exaggerating the successes, and above all by exaggerating how close we may be to a breakthrough.
- hencq 13y agoIt doesn't seem like you actually read the article, but are just commenting on the title. They're not saying any of these innovations are true intelligence. What they're saying is that computers (and robots) are starting to do things that until recently were thought to be solely the domain of humans. They're saying that we're at the start of a new industrial revolution (a second machine age) which will lead to enormous increases in productivity. This article focuses on the positive effects. In their book they actually spend quite a lot of time discussing potential negative effects as well, such as unemployment. You'll be glad to hear that they agree with you that jobs like programming and engineering will be ever more important in that world.
- Houshalter 13y agoAI is marching forward relentlessly. It may or may not be as close as most people think, but were are still getting there within a generation or two at most. Meanwhile almost nothing is being done to solve the friendliness problem. Since it seems to be much more complicated than building normal AI it may never be solved. There might not be a solution - our morality and values are just a bunch of messy evolutionary heuristics, and abstract concepts are hard to define concretely (eg "a human is a bunch of atoms in this specific configuration, but not this specific configuration. It's ok to kill one but not the other.") Humanity's odds aren't good.
- diydsp 13y agoThe effects of AI are an extension of human will. We will succeed or fall with or without AI. AI will only be a factor or artifact in this process, not its determinant.
- Houshalter 13y agoAI brings the possibility of creating minds literally millions of times more intelligent than humans. That kind of power is unimaginable to beings in a world where the dumbest village idiot still shared 99% of his brain structure in common with the greatest genius. An AI will either solve all our problems pretty much instantly, or crush us like ants. It definitely the dominate factor in the future.
- bhouston 13y agoNo one has solved the friendliness problem between humans, so why should it be solvable between humans and AIs.
- Houshalter 13y agoThat's not quite the same thing. We aren't programming the source code of human brains.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoStop complaining about this problem and start putting some damn effort in, if you take it so seriously.
- qwerta 13y agoCurrent AI does not even have a intelligence of rat, we are somewhere around insects.
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoIn terms of general intelligence, that's probably true, but in terms of accomplishing tasks that are useful to humans, AI is far ahead of rats. There are many useful tasks that I can get an AI to do for, but practically none that I can get a rat to do for me.
- dllthomas 13y agoThey surpass us on many individual tasks. Feel free to call it "not real AI", but measured by what it's getting done it's pretty powerful.