3 ms·
> This is just as applicable to people with cars. Something you buy with your own money doesn't shout "privilege" as loudly as something you're given for free.
by smacktoward 13y ago
> This is just as applicable to people with cars.
Something you buy with your own money doesn't shout "privilege" as loudly as something you're given for free. If Google was handing out cars to their employees, the comparison would be more apt.
> Like, you know, almost everyone, including the poor.
Lots of people who live in cities don't have cars, including many of the not-poor. Many (most?) of these people use public transit. Having access to a robust public transit system is generally seen as one of the benefits of living in a dense urban area.
> What in the world is wrong with not taking public transportation? It somehow makes you arrogant, conceited and evil?
No, it makes you look like you're isolated in a cushion of comfort specifically designed to protect you from having to deal with your neighbors. That's not evil, but it's also not the best way to make friends and otherwise seem engaged and non-aloof.
- res0nat0r 13y ago> No, it makes you look like you're isolated in a cushion of comfort specifically designed to protect you from having to deal with your neighbors. That's not evil, but it's also not the best way to make friends and otherwise seem engaged and non-aloof. Ridesharing on a bus with other people is now considered to be aloof? I must have missed the memo.
- protomyth 13y agoRidesharing on a bus that is only available to the blessed employees of a rich tech company using publicly funded stops can be presented as very aloof. Stats and logic are poor defenses against symbols, demonization, and rhetoric in politics.
- owenjones 13y agoGoogle and Apple are paying for the stops now.
- res0nat0r 13y agoSince the Google hate on HN is strong now days (since they have lots of money), shouldn't we be happy they are providing a bus service? These employees might drive to work (worse for the environment) if this bus service was not provided since public transportation might not service where they live.
- protomyth 13y agoProviding the bus service is a sensible and logical idea. It has many benefits. It on the other hand provides a tangible, accessible symbol to demonization and attack with rhetoric. Don't like it? Then you might think a bit when a news network or a comedy show starts hammering a group. [edit] I should add I don't agree with the protestor's plan of action or targets, I'm just trying to explain why and how effective their targeting is. Its a long tradition and very easy for the public to buy into.
- lotu 13y ago> Something you buy with your own money doesn't shout "privilege" as loudly as something you're given for free. If Google was handing out cars to their employees, the comparison would be more apt. However Google "hands out money" to it's employees which they then use to by things like cars. Also Google gives it's employees health care for "free". The buses are a benefit of the job no different than paycheck or health care.