5 ms·
There are many ways talking can help. It can help you avoid the police officer's discretionary punishments. It can help you avoid increased scrutiny that turns
by jjoonathan 13y ago
There are many ways talking can help. It can help you avoid the police officer's discretionary punishments. It can help you avoid increased scrutiny that turns up something incriminating. It's less probable that it will help you avoid being punished due to a baldfaced lie on the part of the officer, since presumably the courts are good at filtering those out, but it's not impossible.
Once you require the services of a trial lawyer, the benefits of talking are off the table and the price of silence looks like pocket change. That's why you hear the advice "never talk to the police." Not because it's a good idea in general (try it next time you get a traffic ticket and tell me how it goes), but because it's a very bad idea in certain very specific cases, which happen to be precisely the cases seen by those giving the advice. Your prior probabilities are different, and your behavior should reflect that.
- pessimizer 13y agoNon-cooperation is just as likely to make a cop lose interest as cooperation. When you cooperate to the degree that you're obligated to, and decline where you're not, that can cause a cop who respects the law and knows that they have no cause to move on, and I've seen it happen often. It can also piss him/her off and make them decide to try to ruin your life. The more you speak to a cop, the more likely you are to say something that you'll regret. The only indication that talking will cause the cop to let you walk away is the gentle look in his eyes. Thinking that you can control the situation is a mistake. If the result of this police contact results in a criminal charge, you may have saved yourself from the worst possible outcome (at the time) by being silent. You can't make a cop not beat you to death by talking. Silence is simply a dominant strategy.
- jjoonathan 13y ago> Non-cooperation is just as likely to make a cop lose interest as cooperation. If they're in a good mood today. Maybe. > The more you speak to a cop, the more likely you are to say something that you'll regret. Yes. My point was that staying completely silent makes it more likely you'll piss off the cop. You'll regret that, too. > Thinking that you can control the situation is a mistake. Right back at you. > You can't make a cop not beat you to death by talking. If you can make a cop beat you to death by (in their eyes) being obstinate, the difference is immaterial. > Silence is simply a dominant strategy. I still don't buy it, unless the cop is already antagonized or you suspect that a judge/jury will be involved before this is all over.
- apayan 13y agoI can't recommend enough watching this video. The law professor explains why you should never speak to the police. It's 46 minutes long, but every minute is pure gold. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE
- siculars 13y agoThis. A thousand times this.
- antr 13y agoI find it ironic that when the cop starts talking he mentions that in the US people should be thankful because they are given a Miranda warning, because, according to him, in other parts of the world like in "Spain and Italy" cops beat up citizens. Last time I check such abuse can't be seen anywhere in Europe. More cop BS.
- Kurtz79 13y agoTo be fair, as an Italian living in Spain, there have been cases in recent years where "cops beat up citizens" in both countries, mostly occurring during large rallies. Still, these occurrences are isolated cases, receive large media attention and are definitely not considered "the norm".
- antr 13y agoDon't take my comment out of context: the video refers to the context of an interrogation, questioning, stop by the police. Not a riot. The policeman follows the presentation by the lawyer regarding the 5th amendment, where it applies, and how it used, where do Miranda warning apply, etc., in line with HN link conversation. This is not a topic of riots - which is quite a different story to the OP.
- brazzy 13y agoOh, it happens. In Germany as well: http://www.dw.de/preventing-police-brutality-in-germany/a-16641839 http://www.dw.de/preventing-police-brutality-in-germany/a-16... But my impression is that it's rather less common than in the USA and the courts, prosecution and conservative public don't side with the police as much.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gcv 13y ago> try it next time you get a traffic ticket and tell me how it goes It worked quite well, thank you. I did not say a word, gave the cop my license and registration as required by law, signed my ticket, and hired a lawyer to get it thrown out later.
- blackzoid 13y agoWhy hire a lawyer for a traffic ticket? Would that not cost more and kind of be a waste of time for everyone.
- gcv 13y agoWhile the fine itself was negligible, a moving violation significantly increases insurance premiums. A lawyer who specializes in fighting traffic tickets is far cheaper than overpaying for insurance for the next decade.
- dagw 13y agoSome people have it has a hobby. I know a guy who on principle never pays a parking or traffic ticket without dragging the whole thing through court for as long as he can. For him the time and money involved are immaterial when compared to the principal of the matter.
- dsego 13y agoIn Croatia you now get a 50% discount if you pay the ticket on the spot.
- seestheday 13y agoOn the spot, like cash directly to the cop? Are you describing a bribe?
- dsego 13y agoNo, not a bribe, just the new laws, see http://www.croatiaweek.com/tag/traffic-fine http://www.croatiaweek.com/tag/traffic-fine. And it seems to be working quite well for now.
- einhverfr 13y agoI disagree and here is why. Even in a perfect world with perfect integrity of the police, volunteering informtion when you are the subject of an investigation is generally a bad idea. The problem is this: "investigation" in any discipline means "finding a story that matches what I can show." This means whatever you say that matches the story will be held on to and whatever you say that doesn't match it will be easily forgotten. This is the root of confirmation bias. It's a very dangerous thing in this context. Yes there are times to talk to the police. Give an alibi along with sources who can confirm it if that is relevant. But say as little as possible. Stick to the minimal details. The less you say, the less they are likely to grab a hold of something you said and hang you with it. But remember: The job of the police is to arrest someone and tell a good plausible story as to why they are guilty. They are there to gather evidence. The DA is there to convince a jury. Nobody can know what really happened who wasn't there. So don't give them ideas.