4 ms·
Some set of people can handle 100% gluten. Since I am not in that set, it clearly is not 100% of the people on Earth. We do not know the distribution of the peo
by jerf 13y ago
Some set of people can handle 100% gluten. Since I am not in that set, it clearly is not 100% of the people on Earth. We do not know the distribution of the people in the middle; we have only begun to see that there is even a question to ask. Science is probably going to need a decade or two to work out the answer to that. (Alas, the studies can not be fast, as they must work at human speeds.)
Further, we have also established that there is a non-empty set of people who can't handle gluten, and often do not realize it for decades at a time. (Again, I am in that set, so I know it exists. For various reasons this can be a difficult reaction to work out, even when you have full-blast Celiac as I do.) This is not making it any easier to work out the distribution. Some of the people who think they can handle 100% gluten may in fact be having more of a negative reaction than they realize.
- ars 13y agoYou implied that "Normal people" can not handle as much gluten as in bread. And I showed you that not only can they handle the small amount in bread, they can handle way more. Now you are trying to back up behind "we don't really know", but actually it's only a minority that have a problem with gluten. The slow experiment has been done: We have been eating gluten for millennia, and only a small number of people had a problem with it. Not eating gluten has become a fad now.
- jerf 13y agoNo, I'm saying there is a continuum of reactions, and we have a poor picture of it. Establishing that there is a non-zero population on one extreme doesn't establish very much about the distribution. You appear to be arguing something along the line of "A: Gluten-free diets have become a fad B: I think that's silly C: Therefore gluten is safe." Yes, I'm interpolating a bit, but it seems to be your general thrust. There's substantial but non-determinative reasons to believe the picture may be much more complicated than that, particularly the rising incidence of celiac disease (which, as the article says, appears to be a real thing and not merely better detection, which was my most-likely belief until I read this article). We've been eating non-zero amounts of gluten for millenia, but a lot of things have changed in the past few decades; how it is processed, what it is in, even perhaps things like I mentioned in my previous post, such as a generation raised on rather more baby formula than before. We have rather poor data, but something's going on. My position has not changed one whit in this conversation.
- ars 13y ago> the rising incidence of celiac disease (which, as the article says, appears to be a real thing and not merely better detection, which was my most-likely belief until I read this article). Autoimmune disorders in general are on the rise. We aren't arguing all that much, except for your statement that gluten is a problem for everyone, but some can handle more some less. I say gluten is perfectly fine for most, and bad only for a small number. Meaning there is no reason to try to reduce gluten in food or blame some nebulous "processing". Or claim that there is more gluten in bread now. All those things are just part of a fad. If a person has a problem with gluten then they do. For everyone else it's a non-issue.