4 ms·
The original blog post was on HN front page yesterday and it got voted down to oblivion. Or hit some sort of threshold. Frankly, I find the original blog post t
by chris_wot 13y ago
The original blog post was on HN front page yesterday and it got voted down to oblivion. Or hit some sort of threshold. Frankly, I find the original blog post to be unbelievably weasily - especially this:
"We believe that if you put the user front and center, you can make every experience for them richer and more meaningful. The Content Services team has embraced this, and today I wanted to share some of our thinking and explain our first steps for putting it into practice."
and then:
"While Mozilla hasn’t always seen eye-to-eye with all viewpoints in the digital content community, particularly the IAB, we think they’d agree that users’ interests should come first, and we want to help their members deliver compelling content to strengthen the Web ecosystem."
This:
* beats around the bush
* starts with spin
* says that advertisers have the best interest of users in mind - and I assure you, they do not.
I am very, very unimpressed.
- Drakim 13y agoEspecially the last part infuriates me, I'm now being done a favor by having ads shoved in my face against my will? There is just no way you can spin that as "helping", it's advertisements, nothing more, nothing less.
- sheetjs 13y ago> it got voted down to oblivion. It was flagged heavily, which shouldn't be a surprise given the heavy pro-Mozilla bias here. (case in point: this post will be downvoted at least a few times in the next few minutes) But to be fair, the ads haven't been rolled out yet, and there's a nonzero chance Mozilla will come to their senses and reverse course. And if not, use a browser that actually values your privacy and safety (my current browser is SRWare Iron https://www.srware.net/en/software_srware_iron.php https://www.srware.net/en/software_srware_iron.php)
- shrikant 13y agoSee this: https://web.archive.org/web/20100614055220/http://chromium.hybridsource.org/the-iron-scam https://web.archive.org/web/20100614055220/http://chromium.h... I'm not sure what's changed since then, but it's worth considering.
- chestnut-tree 13y agoI think people would have (possibly) reacted a little less criticially to this news if the original Mozilla blog post simply got straight to the point i.e. - Mozilla needs to raise money because it's a non-profit. - We're going to place ads on the "directory tiles" page. Questions the Mozilla blog post should have answered, but never did: - Will these ads only ever appear once? - Will these ads re-appear if you clear your cache or cookies? - Can this feature be disabled or bypassed? - What analytics or tracking will the ads use (if any)? I understand that Mozilla needs to diversify its sources of funding. I just wish the Mozilla blog post was written in a plain, straightforward manner. There's far too much padding and "corporate-speak". Phrases such as "publisher transformation", experiences that are "richer and more meaningful", promises to "transform the user’s content experience", and to provide "inherent value to our users" just sound over-inflated and meaningless.