3 ms·
So thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are outside of biology? How does that work? I realize that you are simply quoting a passage and not necessarily personally
by BlackDeath3 13y ago
So thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are outside of biology? How does that work?
I realize that you are simply quoting a passage and not necessarily personally espousing what you wrote.
- ceejayoz 13y agoJust a note, I'm quoting that passage because I (and scientific evidence) disagree with it. Thoughts, feelings, behaviours, and mental illness most certainly have biological bases, which makes Szalz's theories pretty loony.
- floody-berry 13y agoSzasz entire screed appears to be based on mental illnesses not being able to be concretely diagnosed or detected, but then jumping to the conclusion that they are completely made up and abused by society to control everyone's behavior. Once you "accept" his conclusion, it doesn't seem possible to be argued out of it until science advances to an arbitrary point where one feels it adequately explains mental illnesses. "accept" in quotations as I honestly can't tell if his supporters are trolling or honestly believe what they're posting.
- aforrester 13y agoYou have admitted you don't understand Szasz's position, presumably you should be interested in finding out more, see: http://fallibleliving.com/thinkers/szasz http://fallibleliving.com/thinkers/szasz and the reading list at the bottom.