3 ms·
Well... I think I'm underwhelmed, though I'm not quite sure. (Later edit: IMHO, Scriptor's comment invalidates much of this, though I'll leave it for posterity
by jerf 17y ago
Well... I think I'm underwhelmed, though I'm not quite sure.
(Later edit: IMHO, Scriptor's comment invalidates much of this, though I'll leave it for posterity's sake. Thank you.)
Tron 1 wasn't about "lightcycles". If you honor the original movie and understand it, it should be clear that lightcycles are just part of the local landscape because of the lightcycle game, along with the other stuff there. Another contemporaneous computer system would have more local flavor; modern computer systems have yet more richness to draw on.
If Tron 2 is just the standard Hollywood mishmash rehashing of old themes with no particular comprehension of what made the original special, count me out. Tron ought to be something that can be made into a universe as rich as Star Trek, honestly, if you take the core concepts from the first movie and just run with it, but if you're going to get stuck on "remixing" the peripheral concepts, meh.
I might be wrong, and this might be in a "game" context, though it still seems pretty abusive of the lightcycle context.
- philwelch 17y agoMovies are as much (or more) a visual medium than an intellectual medium. Visuals are every bit as important as ideas. But visuals are the easiest part to convey in a trailer, and the lightcycles are the coolest visual element of Tron. It's kind of like how in the reimagined Battlestar Galactica, they kept the Viper launch tubes because it was an awesome visual, and they had the scanny-red-eye Cylons. It didn't keep them from cutting to the heart of the ideas of BSG (survival and escape from a mechanical, inhuman enemy) but the visuals were just as much at the heart. Let me put it this way--if there was a Tron movie that was perfectly true to the ideas of the original, but without any lightcycles at all, that would be just as wrong as making a Tron sequel that's all about lightcycles.
- jerf 17y agoHere's hoping. I do want it to work. I'd love a new, good Tron movie.
- mgcross 17y agoI think you're right on all counts, but.. I was just so into the original movie and the games (arcade, discs, and INTV DD) as a kid that the trailer still makes me giddy!
- Scriptor 17y agoWikipedia has a brief description of this one: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tron_Legacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tron_Legacy I think rather than being a full trailer for the movie, this is more of a single, and visually cool, scene to hype up people not familiar to the original.
- jerf 17y agoThank you for the link. That does render much of the thrust of my criticism incorrect, as it does work in context. Again, here's hoping.
- mgcross 17y agoLooks like it's not all lightcycles: http://www.aintitcool.com/node/41791 http://www.aintitcool.com/node/41791 I love the art direction so far (based on those production stills).
- jonursenbach 17y agoThe deal with the Lightcycles is that over the past 20 years it's become the most recognizable aspect from Tron. It's one of the few things that can give you a large view of the Tron world in a short amount of time and without getting too indepth. That's why the director chose to showcase that in a VFX showcase to get the job; it charts very high on the "WOW"-meter