10 ms·
I get the impression that this is a long, polite way of saying Steve committed suicide. The last time I was on HN and the topic of suicide came up, I wrote kin
by Mz 13y ago
I get the impression that this is a long, polite way of saying Steve committed suicide.
The last time I was on HN and the topic of suicide came up, I wrote kind of a ranty piece that I am not up to editing it (to remove the rantiness) and reposting. The short version: If you know someone who is suicidal and you care about them, spend time with them. In person. Suicide is almost always committed when one is alone.
My credentials: I attempted suicide at 17 and have been hospitalized once or twice for being suicidal in my teens/twenties. In recent years, when medical issues make me mentally and emotionally unstable, my adult sons "babysit" me (in other words, I am not left alone when I might be genuinely suicidal and not just grumpy about life's stressors). I am 48 and I am okay these days in spite of serious medical problems which have somatopsychic impacts (it's a real word -- look it up). So I know it is a method that works.
- sdegutis 13y agoSomeone who's depressed enough to consider suicide probably also experiences a crippling loss of hope which prevents them from taking the steps necessary to make local friends in the first place whom they would be able to reach out to. At least that's been my experience.
- EMRo 13y agoHe did. Thank you for sharing your story. I wish I had been there for him when he needed me like your sons can be there for you.
- Mz 13y ago((HUGS))
- mailshanx 13y agoMy deepest condolences. Hearing about your brother makes me very sad.
- wavefunction 13y agoThe best actors in the world are the depressed. No one who knows me knows how many times I have almost died. I say this in the hopes that it helps with the hurt a bit, though losing your brother never goes away. I lost mine to a motorcycle accident when a driver got impatient with traffic.
- xenophanes 13y agoSo your credentials consist of personal anecdotes? Maybe it's time to start taking the issue more seriously. I think it's a serious issue deserving a more serious approach. For example, you might try reading literature with multiple different perspectives on the issue. Then try to figure out which ideas are right and why. (If you've already done this, forgive me, and please please inform me why Szasz is mistaken, I would love to learn something.)
- Mz 13y agoFYI: I have done lots of reading. I spent time in therapy. Etc. And, for a time, I essentially had an unpaid "consultancy" where parents who had super difficult kids who had been failed by all the experts would get given my email address and talk with me a bit and a year or so later I would hear back that their "impossible" kid was getting their act together. So I strongly suspect that I know what I am talking about, better than most so-called experts.
- gruseom 13y agoI like Szasz too, as well as his hippie counterpart R.D. Laing (whom you might check out if you're interested), but please, don't play intellectual hardball in this thread. The OP just lost his brother.
- xenophanes2 13y agoPeople are spreading very bad, destructive ideas that will result in more dead brothers. I think that's more important than being "nice". Also, Szasz and Laing are closer to opposites than counterparts. See for example: http://www.amazon.com/Antipsychiatry-Quackery-Squared-Thomas-Szasz-ebook/dp/B004E0Z3SG/ http://www.amazon.com/Antipsychiatry-Quackery-Squared-Thomas... Quote from the book, by Szasz: > In the late 1960s, a group of psychiatrists, led by David Cooper (1931-86) and Ronald D. Laing (1927-89), began to criticize conventional psychiatry, especially so-called somatic treatments. But instead of advocating the abolition of Institutional Psychiatry, they sought to replace it with their own brand, which they called "Anti-psychiatry." By means of this dramatic misnomer, they attracted attention to themselves and deflected attention from what they did, which continued to include coercions and excuses based on psychiatric authority and power. Thus, antipsychiatry is a type of psychiatry. The psychiatrist qua health-care professional is a fraud, and so too is the antipsychiatrist. In Psychiatry.The Science of Lies, I showed that psychiatry-an imitation of medicine-is a form of quackery. In this volume, I show that antipsychiatry-a form of alternative psychiatry-is quackery squared. > > For more than a half century, I have consistently asserted two simple but fundamental propositions: mental illnesses do not exist, and coercions justified by them are wrong. Anyone who seeks to help others must eschew the use of force. Not a single antipsychiatrist has ever agreed with these principles or abided by these practices. Subsuming my work under the rubric of antipsychiatry betrays and negates it just as effectively and surely as subsuming it under the rubric of psychiatry. My writings form no part of either psychiatry or antipsychiatry and belong to neither. They belong to conceptual analysis, social-political criticism, and common sense. This is why I rejected, and continue to reject, psychiatry and antipsychiatry with equal vigor.
- pasbesoin 13y agoMz, I continue to appreciate your honest and forthright approach to addressing issues such as this.
- Mz 13y ago(hugs) old friend.
- badclient 13y agoIf you know someone who is suicidal and you care about them, spend time with them. In person. Suicide is almost always committed when one is alone. 100%, although I wish we talked more about the challenge of determining that someone is suicidal. Here's what I wrestle with the most about this. I fear that if I "misdiagnose" someone as suicidal, that I might have now given them the idea that there is such a thing as suicide and it may now become an option, completely backfiring against my goal of helping them. I wonder if there is best practices although it seems a bit silly given we are basically trying to read someone's mind - something that even they(especially them) might not have clarity about.
- Mz 13y agoI am not shy. I tell my kids when I am suicidal. They still live with me and monitor my medical issues closely, so they know when I am being really, really wonky and not just bitching, if that makes sense. It helps that I have an especially close relationship to them. Also, they were raised by me, so are well educated in certain social paradigms.
- ghswa 13y agoAs somebody who's been there (on both sides) I don't believe that anybody who might act on suicidal ideation would not have already considered suicide as an option. I'd say that, if you're worried, starting a conversation about it (in person) is just about the best thing you could do. A "missed diagnosis" is far worse than a "misdiagnosis". Sorry for the pun.
- 13y ago
- einhverfr 13y agoSomething occurs to me when reading what you wrote here. I have heard folks who have struggled with depression (and not just suicidal depression) talk a lot about how important in person time was to recovering generally. I wonder how much depression is a social as opposed to a purely mental/neurological illness. We humans need social contact and this has been known since at least the time of Aristotle (and probably time immemorial). Perhaps you could answer this question: when your adult sons come over and care for you (this is a really great thing btw, and something we have lost as a society), is that in itself theraputic? Or is it just a stop-gap? If it is theraputic, then we are missing a key piece of the discussion in the discourse of mental health.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Mz 13y agoMy sons still live with me. They are both ASD and not very touchy-feely people. But they are very loyal to me. I have a deadly medical condition. Doctors told me "people like you don't get well" and washed their hands of responsibility. Since I have defective genes, it won't hurt their professional reputation if I die while under their care. That feels pretty awful to be on the receiving end of. My sons are taking care of me so I can get well, physically. Part of that is dealing with the brain chemistry fall out as I fight the infections that overran my system, etc. Yes, over time, their devoted care is convincing me someone actually cares about me even though neither of them is the gushy type. They do the important stuff. They provide the care I need. I was a homemaker and full time mom for many years. I took devoted care of them. The three of us are getting physically well together, but I was the sickest. So the care I gave them is coming back to me. That is a first for my life. For the most part, my emotional generosity has gotten me burned by other people. tldr: It wouldn't be inaccurate to say that it is therapeutic.
- camus2 13y agoMy brother committed suicide. He died for nothing,and nobody in the family even knows why he died. 10 years later, I feel like I dont care he died anymore, I just cant feel sorry for people committing suicide, it accomplishes nothing,except destroying a family ,making relatives feel guilty all their life. Suicide is the most selfish thing one can do, that's my opinion.
- marquis 13y agoI'm sorry for your loss.
- duney 13y agoIt isn't selfish of someone to have had a mental illness that drove them to commit suicide. I'm sorry for your loss, but I disagree with your assessment of suicide being a selfish act.
- primitivesuave 13y agoMy best friend from childhood threw himself in front of a train almost exactly 1 year ago (Feb 18th). He had just got his college degree, had an amazing family and all the support in the world. When he took his own life, I had an initial period of unanswerable questions and great sorrow, followed by deep resentment. He had so many people he could have reached out to and so many people reaching out to him, and he just decided to take an easier way out. It was selfish to leave his family hanging like that with so many questions, and the worst part is how difficult it was for them to move on.
- mikeash 13y agoWould you be saying that if he died of cancer instead of mental illness? People have this bizarre idea that mental illness somehow doesn't "count". That you have to fight it, and that if you lose, it's your own fault. You are, right here, blaming the victim of the disease. Your brother died from a mental illness. It killed him, just as surely as cancer or a heart attack might have killed him. You'd never, ever, ever say that someone who's killed by a heart attack is "selfish", so don't do it for mental illnesses either.
- rmc 13y agoThe short version: If you know someone who is suicidal and you care about them, spend time with them. In person. Suicide is almost always committed when one is alone. I read an article about a sports person here who was going to commit suicide, they had it all planned out, and planned the day. But on the day he planned to do it, his mother stayed home instead of going to Mass. Saved his life.
- blueskin_ 13y agoIn person isn't always possible - I'd expect the assumption any friends you know that closely are local from people in most communities, but not here. I've spent time talking to people who I've never met in person who I know consider me a close friend as do I them.
- Mz 13y agoI have also given and gotten support online and by phone. That can also make a difference. But in person, just your presence can prevent someone from acting without having to be confrontational or whatever.