2 ms·
The problem with sinking a lot of money into science is that it only pays dividends if solutions to the big problems actually exist. They may not. It may in f
by lisper 13y ago
The problem with sinking a lot of money into science is that it only pays dividends if solutions to the big problems actually exist. They may not. It may in fact not be possible to do better-than-breakeven fusion on a small (relative to a star) scale. The only way to find out for sure is the hard (and expensive) way.
By way of contrast, when it comes to military technology you're not competing with nature, only with other humans, and so a "solution" (if you'll excuse the irony) is almost certain to be found by one side or the other.
- VladRussian2 13y ago> It may in fact not be possible to do better-than-breakeven fusion on a small (relative to a star) scale. the H-bomb is better-than-breakeven and much smaller than star scale. What you say may be true for Tokamak like confinement schemes whereis H-bomb is inertial confinement, and it works. And it is pretty clear that inertial confinement in several orders of magnitude smaller scale than H-bomb would work too. Look at Sandia Z-machine - an order of magnitude up, and it would get breakeven. Not that anybody really needs it :)
- lisper 13y agoOK, let me be more precise: it may not be possible to do better-than-breakeven fusion on a small scale in a way that makes the resulting energy safely harnessable for useful work.
- arethuza 13y agoJET (Joint European Torus) achieved a Q of 0.7 - with break-even being defined as a Q of 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_European_Torus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_European_Torus ITER is aiming for a Q of 5 for 480 seconds: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER