3 ms·
I think people are reading a bit too much into the name, and into the feedback the app gives. I don't think it's "get rid of all the pastels and your writing wi
by munificent 13y ago
I think people are reading a bit too much into the name, and into the feedback the app gives. I don't think it's "get rid of all the pastels and your writing will be like Heminway's", nor do I even think "get rid of all the warnings" is what it's trying to do.
It is useful for a writer to throw some text at it and see what you can learn. More feedback is almost always better for writers. The trick, is always, is having the judgement to incorporate intelligently.
For example, I stumbled onto a book about procedural content generation in games[1]. As a writer, game programmer, and dedicated fan of roguelikes, if this book were any farther up my alley, it would be banging against the back fence.
But, ugh, when I tried to read it, I just gave up after a few paragraphs. It's not gibberish, but it's almost physically painful to wring the actual information out of it.
And, indeed, when I throw some of those paragraphs at this app, I see:
Paragraphs: 1
Sentences: 31
Words: 833
Characters: 4196
11 of 31 sentences are hard to read.
11 of 31 sentences are very hard to read.
10 adverbs. Aim for 0 or less.
10 words or phrases can be simpler.
13 uses of passive voice. Aim for 6 or less.
If the authors took a bit of advice from this app, they'd end up with a better book. That sounds like a win to me.
[1]: http://pcgbook.com/ http://pcgbook.com/
- whatsreal 13y agoI would venture that the problem with pcgbook.com is not the quality of writing, but the fact that most of the authors are not native english speakers. They seem to be mostly Dutch or at least living in Copenhagen.
- munificent 13y agoEither way, the problem is the quality of the writing. It just may be that the cause of that is the authors not being native English speakers. :) (The fact that they're adopting an academic tone doesn't help either, for that matter.)
- tormeh 13y agoAhahaha! How many textbooks have you read? How many American ones? The majority of them suck. Wikipedia can usually be counted upon to be clearer. And the more academic the books are, the more they suck. Actually, I would guess that how often the words "I", "you" and other personal pronouns referring to the author and reader appear in a book would be a powerful positive predictor of the book's quality. Sure, being non-native doesn't help, but the world of academic writing has far, FAR bigger problems than that.