3 ms·
>the freebies they get are so baked into government What exactly do you understand under freebies [for 100y+ prof org members]? Interesting point about the ol
by Havoc 13y ago
>the freebies they get are so baked into government
What exactly do you understand under freebies [for 100y+ prof org members]?
Interesting point about the older prof members being both anti-union and but joining a prof body. I reckon the two have different functions though. e.g. In my case the only thing I hear from my prof org is messages with a "comply or else" tone. Sure they do set minimum salaries for apprenticeships, but those are so far below market rate that its does even matter. A union in contrast would fit for better work conditions, better pay, better benefits etc.
The only benefit I see is accreditation (admittedly a large benefit)...but that is hardly a freebie (took blood, sweat & many tears).
- pessimizer 13y ago>What exactly do you understand under freebies [for 100y+ prof org members]? Doctors, Lawyers, Realtors, etc. have written 90% of the state laws that they are governed under, and most of the federal ones. They've protected themselves against foreign competition, and shielded themselves against liability.
- rayiner 13y agoWithout necessarily disagreeing with your point, it's interesting to note that software developers bear almost zero liability in practice for all the buggy software they write, while even big name law firms get sued, and lose, regularly on malpractice claims. If Microsoft was as "protected" from malpractice as lawyers are, they would've been sued out of existence for Windows 95/98/ME.
- pessimizer 13y agoOne of the benefits of being unprofessional, I guess, is that the products of our labor are generally considered products of the corporation we work for rather than us as individuals. Google, SAP, etc. get sued all the time, though.
- rayiner 13y agoGoogle, SAP, etc, get sued for things like breach of contract, patent infringement, etc. A lawyer or doctor can get sued for his or her work not meeting the expected standard. Imagine the following bug: a variable can take on values of RED, GREEN, and BLUE. You write a switch statement that fails to consider BLUE. Your product crashes, causing your user $5 million in business losses. You get sued for software malpractice, for failure to consider an obvious alternative case.
- pessimizer 13y agoPerfect case for how professionalism protects clients. We'd all have to carry insurance for that.
- rayiner 13y agoWell I wasn't really suggesting it as a good thing necessarily. I like the spirit that ethical/competency self-regulation instills in the legal profession, but I'm not sure whether the ultimate market impact is a good thing or not. On one hand, I think the financial industry has suffered from a lack of such regulation (e.g. Goldman advising clients to buy certain products while taking an adverse position themselves). On the other hand, the potential liability and need for insurance creates barriers to entry, driving up prices. Given the staggering potential losses from software, professional malpractice insurance probably wouldn't be cheap. But on the third, alien, hand, I think licensure also has a downward effect on the cost of legal services, by making lawyers more fungible than they would otherwise be (in the absence of licensure, the market might come to rely on an even rarer signal of credibility). The economic dynamics of licensed professions are a bit more complex than either side of the "developers should be professionals" debate really appreciates.
- tptacek 13y agoIt's this thought that boils my blood when software developers pretend to be oppressed by the music industry.
- vonmoltke 13y agoThe core problem here is the legal system allowing software companies to successfully disclaim all liability for their software products. Traditional manufacturers can and do get sued over defects in their products.
- declan 13y agoNot only foreign competition, but domestic competition as well. This is how successful cartels operate. A reasonable amount of lawyering is filling out forms that a 30-year veteran paralegal could do better than someone who just graduated from law school. A physician friend is alarmed by the rise of nurse practitioners, who are perfectly able to diagnose and prescribe medicine for routine ailments. Realtors have gone further by trademarking the very term(TM): https://twitter.com/REALTORS https://twitter.com/REALTORS You can probably think of more examples as well.
- pessimizer 13y ago>Realtors have gone further by trademarking the very term(TM) It's even more than that: the NAR actually made up the term, so why wouldn't they have it as a trademark? Of course, that makes it a little difficult to be a non-Realtor real estate agent.
- Mvandenbergh 13y ago>The only benefit I see is accreditation (admittedly a large benefit)...but that is hardly a freebie (took blood, sweat & many tears). Sure, that's by the design of your fellow professionals. It's part of the mechanism for protecting the wages of fully qualified professionals. Unions are often happy enough with much lower apprenticeship wages as well by the way. The two biggest freebies are also the two traditional markers of the professions: -Self regulation: most misconduct is dealt with by peers under rules set by those peers -Protected entry: lawyers and doctors control how many people can enter those professions and who can call themselves a lawyer or a doctor.
- walshemj 13y agoThe BMA and RCN do act in the capacity of a trade union in a lot of ways though.
- potatolicious 13y ago> "e.g. In my case the only thing I hear from my prof org is messages with a "comply or else" tone." That is one of the primary functions of professional organizations. The idea is that you'd rather self-regulate than have the government all up in your business. Disputes and claims of impropriety can avoid the courts (and the public limelight) and be resolved internally. The consequence of that is that you actually have to self-regulate, and that your enforcement arm needs to have teeth. This is how it works in traditional engineering. Most engineering misconduct - short of the catastrophic stuff that makes the evening news - is dealt with internally. For the most part they do a good job of it, which is why they've been able to avoid being outright regulated deeply by the government.