4 ms·
I'll admit it: I will watch this cartoon. Warren Buffett is, next to Taleb and a few others, my favorite modern thinker, and the clip seems to do him justice.
by breck 17y ago
I'll admit it: I will watch this cartoon.
Warren Buffett is, next to Taleb and a few others, my favorite modern thinker, and the clip seems to do him justice. It's ironic how his ideas are so simple they can be accurately presented in cartoon form. It's like reading the Intelligent Investor: business/investing isn't too complex, the hard part is executing on simple premises while keeping your emotions in check for the long term.
- biohacker42 17y agoWhat fascinates me about Warren Buffett... actually it's not him it's everyone else. He takes 0 and 25 and the 25 only if he makes a profit beyond what a conservative investment would. Something like 8% per anum, not sure, the exact number is not important anyway. But your typical hedge fund takes 2 and 20, that's even if they do nothing or lose money. Now here's where it gets interesting. There are literally hundreds of those funds. Doesn't that suggest a massive pent up demand for investment?
- BrentRitterbeck 17y agoIt's a quarter of everything over six percent. Source: How to Pick Stocks Like Warren Buffett, pg. 11.
- falsestprophet 17y agoYeah that was his performance fee when he was managing money through the Buffet partnerships. Now he takes 0 and 0 as Chairman and CEO of Berkshire Hathaway. His compensation is primordially in the appreciation of his (substantial) share of the company.
- BrentRitterbeck 17y agoConsidering the amount shares he owns, I'd rather be the Chairman and CEO of Berkshire than running a hedge fund. In addition, the float from the insurance companies under his umbrella is more than most hedge fund managers will ever manage.
- mediaman 17y agoTaleb is not a good modern thinker. He takes existing, well-known mathematical principles, rewrites them without citation or reference for the layman, and then disparages the people whose work he took and other financial professionals who also understand the mathematics quite well, as if he knows something they don't. He would be a lot less irritating if he (1) didn't claim credit for ideas that aren't his and (2) stopped falsely disparaging people. Buffett, on the other hand, is quite a bit more humble and grounded and provides stable, sage advice. He also credits people a lot more for the work they've done.
- bhewes 17y agoFirst what well-known mathematical principles are you talking about? Second have you read any of his academic papers? All can be found on SSRN. Two of the big ones are "Errors, Robustness, and the Fourth Quadrant" and "Finiteness of Variance is Irrelevant in the Practice of Quantitative Finance." Taleb states "My central idea in The Black Swan is that: rare events cannot be estimated from empirical observation since they are rare. We need an a priori model representation for that; the rarer the event, the more the dependence on aprorism. Further, we do not care about probability (if an event happens or does not happen); we worry about consequences (how much total wealth or total destruction will come from it). Given that the less frequent the event, the more severe the consequence (just consider that the 100 year flood is more severe, and less frequent, than the 10 year flood), our estimation of the CONTRIBUTION of the rare event is going to be massively faulty (contribution is probability times effect; multiply that by estimation error) ; and nothing can remedy it. So the rarer the event, the less we know about its role --and the more we need to make it up with an extrapolative, generalizing theory. Hence model error is more consequential in the tails and some representations ARE MORE FRAGILE than others..... Nobody before has examined my problem in the history of thought, let alone systematize the idea of decision-making under certain classes of ignorance." I am sure he would be excited if someone could show him that his idea is not original.
- andreyf 17y agoUm, I had this idea sometime around middle school, when we learned fractions, and probability was an example the teacher used. I still remember his response, which was rather satisfying - that in many systems, things break down at edge cases, and that's to be expected. It was a great class - a similar insight Mr. Hawks helped me have is that there's much less of a difference between how people reason about $6 billion and $7 billion than between $5 and $500, even though the former is a much larger gap. This stuff is common sense, and the con is probably older than modern civilization - the author tells you a neat tidbit of somewhat counter-intuitive reasoning, then pretends like he's endowed you with a secret which makes you smarter than most trained economists. You eat it up because you love the idea that you're smarter than economic experts. Bullshit.