6 ms·
Let’s get realistic here shall we? Building an alternative to Gmail? Nope. We can’t do that. We don’t have the resources. And if we were to charge people for a
by elorant 13y ago
Let’s get realistic here shall we? Building an alternative to Gmail? Nope. We can’t do that. We don’t have the resources. And if we were to charge people for a service like that in exchange of extra security the majority wouldn’t give a damn.
The thing is that NSA has the ability to attack the infrastructure. If for example they can go to carrier providers and monitor the pipe no matter what we’d do on top of that would be futile. Furthermore, they can backdoor cryptography algorithms-which to my opinion is the scariest from all the revelations regarding NSA. So even if we move everyone to SSL we wouldn’t know if that’s enough.
The financial pain you’re referring to cuts both ways. If you were to boycott commercial solutions then you’d have to go and find alternatives. Which could be relatively easy for tech-savvy individuals but what about companies? They wouldn’t do it. Simply as that. No one would go out of their way to install an alternative to Exchange Server in order to put pressure on Microsoft. It’s not realistic.
Basically what we need is a new Internet. We have to change everything. I don’t know if that’s even feasible but my guess is that even if it was it will take a lot of time.
- blowski 13y agoI agree with most of what you say, but this is a bit pessimistic: > Building an alternative to Gmail? Nope. We can’t do that. We don’t have the resources. When you think about it, most of the internet depends on open source software built by "us". Programming languages, databases, web servers, content management systems, statistical analysis, image manipulation, and yes, email clients/servers. Given all that, a self-hosted email application should be possible. I suspect the reason we don't do it is not because we don't have the resources, but because... actually I don't know why we don't. Perhaps all the investment slush funds have made us lazy and selfish. Perhaps the social networks and mobile games have made us less creative. Perhaps some of the fanatical open source software wars have put us off doing the same thing.
- Retric 13y agoThe actual answer relates to the email protocol. Sure, you can setup your private messing system and there are plenty of them out there, but if you want to receive email from someones gmail account you need to hook into DNS which is under a government's control you also need a few dedicated machines to handle the load. Granted you may trust .TV or wherever, but as the pirate bay found out when the US and it's allies really want something it's surprisingly hard to find someone that's really willing to stand up to them.
- higherpurpose 13y agoI think the solutions are coming, and we're beginning to see the seeds of that with stuff like DarkMail protocol, TPB's upcoming anti-censorship browser, the P2P Twitter alternative, Twister. However, I think the big problem with these will be adoption. I that first off before the masses move to such services, the current status quo needs to become quite bad. Bittorent adoption grew because the MPAA kept killing stuff like Napster and Kazaa, and then they got the government to seize all streaming website domains, to the point where nobody had an alternative except using Bittorent. If TPB can't be accessed anymore, it will push millions to use TPB's upcoming browser. There's another problem with some of these. They are stand-alone apps. I think what will get us the "encrypted by default Internet" and much better privacy and anonymity will emerge out of the Bitcoin community. Something like http://www.ethereum.org http://www.ethereum.org which plans to build an Internet-like platform might give us that. The reason this might become more popular is that it's not just an app. It's a platform on which you'll see all sorts of very secure and private apps appear, to the point where most of your "Internet usage" is done on that platform, whether it's for visiting your most important websites, or chatting with friends or e-mailing them. I think that's how we'll get that secure by default Internet. I'm skeptical of IETF and the like fixing the current Internet, because I think there are too many stakeholders in the current Internet that will fight against any serious changes to how the Internet works. I fully expect Google, for example, to fight against any proposal for anonymity. So the real changes will have to happen bottom-up, rather than top-down, and grow naturally. Hopefully this won't take too long, though.
- bad_user 13y ago> Bittorent adoption grew because the MPAA kept killing stuff like Napster and Kazaa, and then they got the government to seize all streaming website domains, to the point where nobody had an alternative except using Bittorent. Personally, I ended up using Bittorrent because it was superior to the alternative that's popular in my country (DC++). Because it is peer to peer and because the client can download from multiple seeds at the same time, Bittorent makes it easy to saturate my download bandwidth. From a publisher's perspective for legal torrents (e.g. think of Ubuntu.com) it's better to distribute a torrent link on your website, than it is to provide a direct download link or to upload your stuff on Kazza, or Napster, or Dropbox, or Megaupload, or whatever. Notice how bandwidth and finding a host for popular stuff is a problem, being the reason for why people still use SourceForge. I cannot agree with you - people don't switch because of government-related actions. People switch when the alternative is superior. Let me give you another success story waiting to happen - Bittorent Sync makes it easy to synchronize stuff in your network. It's still rough, but if I were Dropbox, that's the competition I would fear. Anyway, peer2peer when implemented right works better than the server-client model, at least on broadband connections that can afford the upload (sadly, doesn't work so well on mobile phones, either because of battery life or bandwidth limits, but these are limitations that are not going to exist in the future). If you implement something that works and is friendly to users, then it can win in the marketplace.
- curun1r 13y ago> When you think about it, most of the internet depends on open source software built by "us". I wonder whether that could be a possible "fix" to get companies to push back harder against the government. If the various OSS licenses were amended to include a clause that forbade the use of the software to aid government surveillance, it would force providers to choose between continuing to leverage open source software and continuing to cooperate with the government.
- vog 13y ago> Building an alternative to Gmail? Nope. We can’t do that. We don’t have the resources. Agreed. We don't have the resources. > Basically what we need is a new Internet. We have to change everything. But that would need even more resources!
- ntaso 13y agoLet’s get realistic here shall we? Building an alternative to Gmail? Nope. We can’t do that. The protocol is called IMAP and the client is called <insert-random-email-client-here>. Email is old and just about every email client does its job sufficiently good to achieve what it was made for: writing and sending emails. With IMAP, everything is even synced across all devices. Gmail is actually the LEAST important thing to use in my opinion. If people are unwilling to sacrifice a relatively unnecessary software like Gmail, I don't see any chance in boycotting products/companies at all.
- hrjet 13y agoYou do realize that IMAP and email client are just a small part of Gmail?
- ntaso 13y agoSo, what's the indispensable feature of Gmail you absolutely need?
- noblethrasher 13y agoRidiculously smart spam filtering.
- dublinben 13y agoSpamassassin.
- rhizome31 13y agoSpamassassin is not as good as Gmail but I still don't want Gmail. I don't mind giving up a bit of confort for political reasons. The same way I don't mind using DuckDuckGo with ixquick (!ix) and startpage (!sp) fallbacks instead of Google. It's a bit less confortable, but I can still find what I need.
- baudehlo 13y ago
- frabcus 13y agoOf course we can! It looked like Internet Explorer was a permanent browser monopoly just over a decade ago. The Spread Firefox campaign - a crowd marketing campaign - fixed that. Combined, of course with a well made browser. The result was that Apple and Google could later compete on another level with Microsoft (without Spread Firefox, websites wouldn't have worked on iPhones or Chrome). Something similar can absolutely be done again.
- davidw 13y ago> The Spread Firefox campaign - a crowd marketing campaign - fixed that. Combined, of course with a well made browser. Thanks, almost entirely, to Google's money.
- pdpi 13y agoThanks, almost entirely, to Mozilla's efforts. Yes, Mozilla gets most of its income from Google right now, but saying that Spread Firefox's success was almost entirely attributable to Google's money is tantamount to saying that Mozilla would've been unable to secure any other source of funding.
- arjie 13y agoGoogle paid Mozilla for a service the latter rendered. It wasn't a donation.
- vacri 13y agoIt looked like Internet Explorer was a permanent browser monopoly just over a decade ago. I remember noting it was odd in the late 90s that IE was free on computers (because they were all Windows...) yet half the people I knew paid money for this Netscape thing.
- quadrangle 13y agoAm I crazy? I remember using Netscape myself and I'm sure I never paid for it.
- dagw 13y agoBasically what we need is a new Internet. Anybody else remember the Internet2 push from the late 90's?
- artmageddon 13y agoWhatever happened to that? I thought it was still around by still very niche.
- dublinben 13y agoIt's limited to educational institutions.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoWhat does our primary electronic communication system look like in 10 years? A slightly improved gmail? Yeah, probably not. Still plenty of room for innovation out there.
- Ronsenshi 13y ago> Basically what we need is a new Internet. We have to change everything. I don’t know if that’s even feasible but my guess is that even if it was it will take a lot of time. Problem of creating new Internet lies in the infrastructure. We can't just build it upon current network to which NSA (and other agencies) already has an access. It maybe encrypted, but as you pointed yourself, encryption can be broken. So, personally, i can see this new Internet only if there was a new way to send and receive data with less infrastructure overhead as there is now. And that might be possible in the future with stuff like quantum teleportation.