3 ms·
I taught a college pre-calc course for a short time. We had "show your work" exams, so I got to see how students solved problems. I think that many of them had
by analog31 13y ago
I taught a college pre-calc course for a short time. We had "show your work" exams, so I got to see how students solved problems. I think that many of them had been taught "test taking skills" in high school, including a method of finding answers to math problems by guess-and-try or process of elimination. Basically, their teachers had hacked the standardized testing process. (Probably including the AP exam).
Honestly, college math wasn't much better. Rather than confronting them with critical thought, we simply replaced the old hack with a new one:
1. Recognize the "form" of the problem, corresponding to a section in the textbook.
2. Plug the parameters of the problem into an equation solvable by the method of that section.
3. Apply the method and write the answer.
When I realized this, I told my students about it.
There was a chapter on maxima and minima. But the only function they had learned was the quadratic, so all optimization problems boiled down to arranging things into a quadratic. The text had them graphing each quadratic. I decided it would be more interesting for the kids to see how we make our own formulas, so we derived one for the optimum of a quadratic function, and memorized it.
Now is this math or not? Well, I think there's a place in math that involves classifying the forms of expressions and equations, sort of like taxonomy in biology. But it shouldn't be the only thing.