23 ms·
I have to disagree with this. For example, he attacks geometric proofs. Obviously, geometric proofs are useless and pointless, except that they represent a ve
by Pxtl 13y ago
I have to disagree with this.
For example, he attacks geometric proofs. Obviously, geometric proofs are useless and pointless, except that they represent a very simple and intuitive sandbox for learning proofs. Which is fantastic. How better would you teach kids to understand what math means beyond arithmetic? You give them a bunch of simple rules that make obvious sense, and then show them how you can use those to prove non-obvious things.
Our curriculum has all but dropped geometric proofs and the kids are poorer for it.
I think our curriculum here in North America (I'm in Ontario, but I imagine Americans have very similar classes) is fine - the problem is that people are afraid to make the problems really hard and force the students to really stretch their skills beyond just "same as the example but change the numbers". That's what's missing, not some esoteric subject matter, just taking the existing tools in the existing toolbox and pushing the kids to build higher instead of more.
- j2kun 13y agoIt's the way geometry is taught, not the content, that is the problem. This is essentially the argument for all types of math; they aren't "math" because they're taught in a way that removes all the math and leaves... what exactly?